“…The orbital angular momentum, L , of each state is labelled in the rightmost column and conformity/non-conformity with each of our three criteria is indicated by Y/N (for yes/no) in the remaining three columns. for Na x CoO 2 ·yH 2 O have measured the temperature dependence of either specific heat 23,24 or relaxation rates (nuclear magnetic resonance 5 , nuclear quadrupole resonance 25,26 and muon spin relaxation, μSR 3,27 ). In all of these works, the authors agree that the low-temperature behaviour of the DOS is not exponential, indicating the absence of a full gap.…”