Evidence for Urban–Rural Disparity in Temperature–Mortality Relationships in Zhejiang Province, China

Abstract

Background:Temperature-related mortality risks have mostly been studied in urban areas, with limited evidence for urban–rural differences in the temperature impacts on health outcomes.Objectives:We investigated whether temperature–mortality relationships vary between urban and rural counties in China.Methods:We collected daily data on 1 km gridded temperature and mortality in 89 counties of Zhejiang Province, China, for 2009 and 2015. We first performed a two-stage analysis to estimate the temperature effects on mortality in urban and rural counties. Second, we performed meta-regression to investigate the modifying effect of the urbanization level. Stratified analyses were performed by all-cause, nonaccidental (stratified by age and sex), cardiopulmonary, cardiovascular, and respiratory mortality. We also calculated the fraction of mortality and number of deaths attributable to nonoptimum temperatures associated with both cold and heat components. The potential sources of the urban–rural differences were explored using meta-regression with county-level characteristics.Results:Increased mortality risks were associated with low and high temperatures in both rural and urban areas, but rural counties had higher relative risks (RRs), attributable fractions of mortality, and attributable death counts than urban counties. The urban–rural disparity was apparent for cold (first percentile relative to minimum mortality temperature), with an RR of 1.47 [95% confidence interval (CI): 1.32, 1.62] associated with all-cause mortality for urban counties, and 1.98 (95% CI: 1.87, 2.10) for rural counties. Among the potential sources of the urban–rural disparity are age structure, education, GDP, health care services, air conditioners, and occupation types.Conclusions:Rural residents are more sensitive to both cold and hot temperatures than urban residents in Zhejiang Province, China, particularly the elderly. The findings suggest past studies using exposure–response functions derived from urban areas may underestimate the mortality burden for the population as a whole. The public health agencies aimed at controlling temperature-related mortality should develop area-specific strategies, such as to reduce the urban–rural gaps in access to health care and awareness of risk prevention. Future projections on climate health impacts should consider the urban–rural disparity in mortality risks. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP3556

Comparison of life loss per death attributable to ambient temperature among various development regions: a nationwide study in 364 locations in China

“…Several studies have reported that socioeconomic factors independently affected the association of temperature with mortality counts [5,9,10]. For instance, several studies reported that temperaturemortality relationships had difference between urban and rural areas [11][12][13], gross domestic product (GDP) and average educational years also could explain spatial heterogeneity of temperature-related effects [10,14,15]. Based on these, we hypothesize that low socioeconomic development regions (LDRs) maybe more vulnerable to ambient temperature than high development regions (HDRs), which has not been examined in the previous studies at national level.…”

Spatial Variability of Heat-Related Mortality in Barcelona from 1992–2015: A Case Crossover Study Design

“…However, exposure risk assessment requires consideration of all microenvironments where humans spend most of the time [12]. The weather-related mortality associations in a city using exposure variables from one local weather station or the average from a network of sites could induces exposure measurement error or biases in the estimates [13]. More recently, satellite-measured land surface temperature (LST) has been used to identify the temperature variations at a high spatial resolution [14].…”

“…However, LST cannot serve as a proper proxy for the daily mean temperature mainly due to their sparse temporal coverage (one measurement per day) [15]. Numerous studies have spatially interpolated temperature data from multiple measurement sites, but this is often limited by the sparse distribution of weather stations that cannot accurately measure temperature variations within a study area [13].…”

Spatial Variability of Municipality-wise Heat and Cold Mortality in Japan with Respect to Temperature and Economic States

“…More localized features of heat stroke casualties have been investigated for many parts of the world with respect to urban-rural difference (Tan et al 2010;Gabriel and Endlicher 2011;Li et al 2017;Hu et al 2019) and intra-city variations (Vaneckova et al 2010;Chan et al 2012;Hondula et al 2012;Harlan et al 2013;Rosenthal et al 2014;Madrigano et al 2015;Kim and Kim 2017;Schinasi et al 2018), although these studies target "heatrelated mortality" defined by excessive mortality under high temperature rather than heat-stroke deaths in a nar- row sense. While some of them paid attention to both climatic and social factors, such as economic state and education, the results are not sufficiently consistent to provide a unified view of the spatial variation of heatrelated mortality.…”