Evidence for the positive impact of ISO 9001 and ISO 15189 quality systems on laboratory performance – evaluation of immunohaematology external quality assessment results during 19 years in Austria

Abstract

Background ISO 9001 and ISO 15189 have been established as continuative models for quality systems beyond national laws, mandatory standards and guidelines of expert associations regarding analytical and organisational performance of medical laboratories and transfusion services. Although widely used, their impact on laboratory performance has not been investigated. Methods We retrospectively analysed the results of 167 laboratories in 59 distributions of the Austrian red cell immunohaematology external quality assessment (EQA) scheme in the years 1999-2017. The performance for each parameter and trends of individual participants were compared with respect to certification or accreditation status of participants' quality systems and to laboratory type. Results Considering more than 52,000 EQA results, the absence or presence of a laboratory quality management system showed different error rates. Laboratories with ISO 9001 or ISO 15189 certification/accreditation had 0.7% incorrect results, while this rate was doubled without such quality systems (1.4%, p=0.0002). Statistically significant error reductions were seen upon ISO 9001/ISO 15189 implementation (1.3% before vs. 0.7% after; p=0.0468). Transfusion services had fewer errors (0.9%) compared to hospital and independent laboratories (both 1.2%). Conclusions Implementation and maintenance of quality systems according to ISO 9001 or ISO 15189 as well as laboratory specialisation result in better analytical performance as can be seen in immunohaematology EQA results. The conclusion is that these results apply to other laboratory tests and perhaps to other areas of health care.

The Significance of External Quality Assessment Schemes for Molecular Testing in Clinical Laboratories

“…In general, with regard to the analytical phase, accreditation enhances a laboratory’s performance, meaning that they have overall fewer analysis errors, deviating results or technical errors than non-accredited laboratories [ 45 , 52 ]. These results demonstrate the importance of EQA participation in reaching a successful performance.…”

An overview of medical diagnostic laboratories in South Africa that meet the international standard of accreditation: ISO 15189

“…22 Maintenance of the quality systems according to the standard and laboratory's processes result in an improved assurance of performance. 23 Management requirements proposed by ISO 15189 for medical laboratories are based on ISO 9001. 24 This is mainly because all management clauses in ISO 9001 are the same as those in ISO 15189.…”

Errors within the total laboratory testing process, from test selection to medical decision-making – A review of causes, consequences, surveillance and solutions

“…In addition, the vast majority of laboratories have now implemented a quality management system according to the requirements of ISO 15189, ISO 9001, or other national standards (13,14). An interesting relationship has been published by Buchta et al, who showed that laboratories using an immunohaematology external quality assessment (EQA) scheme with ISO 9001 certification or ISO 15189 accreditation have lower error rates than others (15). However, further studies are needed to evaluate the improvement of error rates by the use of quality management systems.…”