We present a broadband ferromagnetic resonance study of the Gilbert damping enhancement ( α) due to spin pumping in NiFe/Pt bilayers. The bilayers, which have negligible interfacial spin memory loss, are studied as a function of the Pt layer thickness (t Pt ) and temperature (100-293 K). Within the framework of diffusive spin pumping theory, we demonstrate that Dyakonov-Perel (DP) or Elliot-Yaffet (EY) spin relaxation mechanisms acting alone are incompatible with our observations. In contrast, if we consider that the relation between spin relaxation characteristic time (τ s ) and momentum relaxation characteristic time (τ p ) is determined by a superposition of DP and EY mechanisms, the qualitative and quantitative agreement with experimental results is excellent. Remarkably, we found that τ p must be determined by the out-of-plane electrical resistivity (ρ) of the Pt film and hence its spin diffusion length (λ Pt ) is independent of t Pt . Our work settles the controversy regarding the t Pt dependence of λ Pt by demonstrating its fundamental connection with ρ considered along the same direction of spin current flow.