Evidence-based practice: a critical reflection

Petr, Christopher G.; Walter, Uta M.

doi:10.1080/13691450802567523

Cited by 24 publications

(5 citation statements)

References 36 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Additional empirical support is needed to determine the extent to which existing practice guidelines might be effective and applicable. Petr and Walter (2009) posited that a fuller understanding is formed when research findings are considered in combination with the wisdom of practitioners and mental health consumers. The voice of those with the lived experience of SMI has received little attention in the literature.…”

Section: Rationale For the Current Studymentioning

confidence: 99%

Strategies for Incorporating Spirituality as Part of Recovery-Oriented Practice: Highlighting the Voices of those with a Lived Experience

Starnino

2014

Families in Society

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Spirituality has received attention as a potential recovery-enhancing resource for people with psychiatric disabilities, yet practice guidelines for addressing spirituality among this population remain underdeveloped. This article presents the perspectives of those with the lived experience of serious mental illness regarding what constitutes effective practice for addressing spirituality. In-depth qualitative interviews were conducted with 18 adults with psychiatric disabilities who had diverse spiritual beliefs. Participants recommended a variety of provider strategies ranging from nondirective (e.g., effective listening) to increasingly directive (e.g., recommending spiritual readings). Participants also expressed the need for providers to be able to address spiritually related challenges, including spiritual abuse, stigma, and delusions with religious content. The study is relevant for recovery-oriented social workers and related mental health professionals.

show abstract

Section: Rationale For the Current Studymentioning

confidence: 99%

Strategies for Incorporating Spirituality as Part of Recovery-Oriented Practice: Highlighting the Voices of those with a Lived Experience

Starnino

2014

Families in Society

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…They, however, ignore our point later in that same paragraph that states the objective of evidencebased policing is not to completely omit these sources of knowledge. Indeed, many agree that experiential knowledge is a key piece of the evidence-based policing puzzle (Ratcliffe, 2014), and thus more closely aligns with the progressive approach to evidence-based practice outlined in the very source cited by Staller and Koerner (2021) to make the point about hegemonic epistemology and ontology (Petr & Walter, 2009). A further hole in the epistemological and ontological hegemony argument is that many evidence-based policing scholars recognize the importance of both qualitative and quantitative methods (Mitchell, 2018), which is another point made by Petr and Walter (2009).…”

mentioning

confidence: 86%

“…Indeed, many agree that experiential knowledge is a key piece of the evidence-based policing puzzle (Ratcliffe, 2014), and thus more closely aligns with the progressive approach to evidence-based practice outlined in the very source cited by Staller and Koerner (2021) to make the point about hegemonic epistemology and ontology (Petr & Walter, 2009). A further hole in the epistemological and ontological hegemony argument is that many evidence-based policing scholars recognize the importance of both qualitative and quantitative methods (Mitchell, 2018), which is another point made by Petr and Walter (2009). Under the evidence-based policing paradigm -and indeed within scientific inquiry more generally -they have different purposes: quantitative methods allow us to determine what works (or does not), whereas qualitative methods provide insight on why something worked (or did not).…”

mentioning

confidence: 86%

Tidying Up A Few Misconceptions Around Evidence-Based Policing: Reply to Staller and Koerner (2021)

Koziarski

Huey

2021

Preprint

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In this piece we reply to a commentary from Staller and Koerner (2021) on our work entitled, #Defund or #Re-Fund? Re-Examining Bayley's Blueprint for Police Reform. In short, we agree on the necessity of reflexivity within policing research and the area of evidence-based policing more specifically, but also see this reply as an opportunity to clarify some misconceptions around evidence-based policing and what it means to be 'evidence-based'. More specifically, we touch upon the flexibility of evidence-based policing to be implemented in tandem with other reform approaches, the value of experiential knowledge and qualitative methods within evidence-based policing, and the confounding of evidence and evidence-based. We conclude on the point of reflexivity and put out a call for follow-up studies that examine the implications of evaluated police practices.

show abstract

“…En el marco de este paradigma, la evidencia se deriva básicamente de la tradición científica occidental, y sitúa los diseños experimentales como la regla de oro de toda investigación (Petr y Walter, 2009). La traslación de este movimiento a los procesos de intervención social y sociosanitaria resulta sin duda necesaria, en la medida en que reivindica elementos razonables pero hasta ahora poco presentes en este campo, tales como el carácter científico de la intervención social, la necesidad de no improvisar y de no guiarse sólo por el sentido común, sino también por el contraste y la verificación de la intervención; la necesidad de elevar, en definitiva, la intervención social a una fase más adulta mediante la selección rigurosa de las intervenciones más efectivas.…”

Section: Iraila·septiembre 2015unclassified

Reordenación de la red de recursos y programas para la inclusión social de Gipuzkoa

2015

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Eguía-Careaga Fundazioaren SIIS Dokumentazio eta Ikerketa Zentroak Gipuzkoako Foru AldundiarenPolitika Sozialeko Departamentuarentzako txosten bat burutu zuen 2015eko urtarrila eta ekaina bitartean lurralde horretako gizarteratzeko baliabideen sarea eta programak berrantolatzearen inguruan. Artikulu honetan laburbiltzen da txosten hori, eta lurraldeko pobrezia eta gizartebazterketaren egoeren eboluzioa eta gizartebazterketa egoeren arretarako sistemaren tamaina aztertu ondoren, bertan biltzen dirabatzuetan kontrajarriak diren-txostena burutzeko elkarrizketaturiko eragileen iritziak. Artikuluak ondorio gisara jasotzen ditu bazterkeria egoeran edo arriskuan dauden pertsonen arreta hobetzeko zenbait gomendio. Gako-hitzak:Gizarteratzea, gizarte-zerbitzuak, zerbitzuen sarea, zerbitzuen antolakuntza, gomendioak, Gipuzkoa.Entre enero y junio de 2015, el SIIS Centro de Documentación y Estudios de la Fundación Eguía-Careaga elaboró un informe para el Departamento de Política Social de la Diputación Foral de Gipuzkoa sobre la reordenación de la red de recursos y programas para la inserción social en ese territorio. Este artículo sintetiza dicho informe: tras analizar la evolución de la pobreza y la exclusión en el territorio, así como las principales magnitudes del sistema de atención a ambos fenómenos, recoge los posicionamientos -en ocasiones encontradosque sobre la reordenación de la red de atención mantienen los agentes entrevistados para la realización del informe. El artículo concluye con una serie de propuestas genéricas para mejorar la atención a las personas en situación o riesgo de exclusión. Palabras clave:Inclusión social, servicios sociales, red de servicios, organización de servicios, recomendaciones, Gipuzkoa.

show abstract

Evidence-based practice: a critical reflection

Cited by 24 publications

References 36 publications

Strategies for Incorporating Spirituality as Part of Recovery-Oriented Practice: Highlighting the Voices of those with a Lived Experience

Strategies for Incorporating Spirituality as Part of Recovery-Oriented Practice: Highlighting the Voices of those with a Lived Experience

Tidying Up A Few Misconceptions Around Evidence-Based Policing: Reply to Staller and Koerner (2021)

Reordenación de la red de recursos y programas para la inclusión social de Gipuzkoa

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About