Evidence-based medicine: assessment of knowledge of basic epidemiological and research methods among medical doctors

Abstract

Background: An understanding of statistical methods and basic epidemiology are crucial for the practice of modern medicine. Aims: To assess (1) the knowledge of basic methods of conducting research and data analysis among residents and practicing doctors and (2) the effect of country of medical school graduation, professional status, medical article reading and writing experience on the level of this knowledge. Methods: Data were collected by means of a supervised self-administered questionnaire, which was distributed among doctors at Soroka Medical Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel. The questionnaire included 10 multiple-choice questions on basic epidemiology and statistics, and respondent demographical data. Results: Of the 260 eligible doctors, 219 (84.2%) returned completed questionnaires. Of the 219 doctors, 50% graduated more than 8.5 years ago, 39.7% were specialists and the remaining were residents. The most frequent specialty was internal medicine (37.4%). Israel was the most frequent country of graduation (45.7%), followed by the former Soviet Union (Eastern medical education; 38.4%). The median total score of knowledge was 4 of 10 questions (interquartile range 2-6). A higher score was associated with a Western medical education, being a specialist, shorter elapsed time since graduation, higher number of publications and self-reported reading of ''methods'' and ''discussion'' sections in scientific articles. Conclusion: This study found a low level of knowledge of basic principles of research methods and data analysis among doctors, and this knowledge considerably differed by country of medical school graduation.

Use of email in communication between the Finnish primary healthcare system and general practitioners

“…Moreover, it has recently been shown that there are differences in capability regarding the use of data and research information depending on the country in which a medical doctor has graduated. 15 Of course language may have been one interfering factor which explains the observed phenomena. However, we know that in the Finnish system students get very familiar with messaging via computerised systems while this is not…”

Conocimientos de los alumnos de últimos años de Medicina y residentes sobre indicadores de riesgo epidemiológico utilizados en ensayos clínicos

“…Al revisar investigaciones publicadas en el área de medicina basada en evidencias, se encontró que, en general, el nivel de estos conocimientos en estudiantes y graduados de medicina es bajo, con porcentajes de acierto entre el 40 y 60% en preguntas relacionadas con indicadores de riesgo (3,15,16) . A pesar que estos estudios nos pueden dar una idea del nivel de conocimientos (en temas de MBE) en otras poblaciones, sus resultados no son comparables con los obtenidos en la presente investigación ya que en aquellas se mide el nivel de conocimiento de los conceptos sobre indicadores de riesgo epidemiológico y no su comprensión o aplicación (17) .…”

How much do you need: a randomised experiment of whether readers can understand the key messages from summaries of Cochrane Reviews without reading the full review

“…9 Indeed, physicians spent, on average, less than 2 min searching for an answer to a clinical question 10 which highlights the need for summaries to be clear and concise; otherwise, errors in interpretation may be made which could impact on policy and medical practice.…”