Evaluation of the Stability of Internal Fixation Constructs in a Low Distal Tibia Extra-articular Cadaveric Fracture Model: A Comparative Biomechanical Study

Abstract

Introduction Despite the recent advances in implant design, the choice of an internal fixation modality for extra-articular distal tibia fractures remains controversial, and there is sparse literature comparing the stability of intramedullary nails and locked plates for such fractures. Hence, we conducted a biomechanical study on an AO type 43A3 tibia fracture cadaveric model stabilized by four different constructs, viz., intramedullary (IM) interlocking nail, anteromedial plate, anterolateral plate, and posterior plate. An AO type 43A3 fracture is defined as an extra-articular fracture of the distal tibia with metaphyseal comminution. Methods A biomechanical comparative study on formalin-preserved human cadaveric tibiae was undertaken; a total of four groups were tested, with eight bones in each group. Out of the 32 cadaveric tibiae, 19 bones belonged to male cadavers, and 13 bones belonged to female cadavers. All bones were dissected from age-appropriate cadavers and fixed with an implant, followed by the creation of a 1 cm osteotomy to simulate an AO type 43A3 fracture. All fixation constructs were subjected to three-point bending tests in the anteroposterior (AP) and mediolateral (ML) planes. Three parameters, viz., bending stiffness, peak fracture gap angle, and neutral zone, were evaluated on the load-displacement curves. A fixation construct was deemed biomechanically stable if it had a high bending stiffness, a low neutral zone (inherent toggle in the construct by its weight), and a low peak fracture gap angle. Results Out of the four implants tested, locked IM nails exhibited the maximum biomechanical stability in terms of higher bending stiffness, smaller peak fracture gap angle, and smaller neutral zones. The IM nail exhibited the highest bending stiffness in the AP plane, and the anterolateral plate had the lowest bending stiffness, and the difference was statistically significant (p= 0.032). In the AP plane, the anterolateral plate exhibited a bending stiffness of 1.51 ± 0.69 Nm/degree, whereas the intramedullary nail exhibited a bending stiffness of 2.34 ± 0.81 Nm/degree, and the posterior locked plate had a bending stiffness of 1.57 ± 0.44 Nm/degree. In the ML plane, the anterolateral plate exhibited the highest neutral zone as compared to the intramedullary nail, which had the lowest neutral zone, and the difference was statistically significant (p = 0.019). The intramedullary nail exhibited the lowest neutral zone of 0.46 ± 0.31 degrees, whereas the posterior locked plate exhibited a neutral zone of 0.78 ± 0.43 degrees in the ML plane. The anterolateral plate exhibited a neutral zone of 1.43 ± 1.00 (expressed as mean ± SD) degrees in the mediolateral plane. Conclusion Our biomechanical study supports the recommendations of using a locked intramedullary nail for AO type 43A3 fractures. We concluded that the anterolateral plate construct exhibited the least biomechanical stability, in terms of lower AP bending stiffn...