Evaluation of Spatial Processing in Virtual Reality Using Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI)

Abstract

While the ecological validity of virtual reality (VR) applications is usually assessed by behavioral data or interrogation, an alternative approach on a neuronal level is offered by brain imaging methods. Because it is yet unclear if 3D space in virtual environments is processed analogically to the real world, we conducted a study investigating virtual spatial processing in the brain using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Results show differences in VR spatial brain processing as compared to known brain activations in reality. Identifying differences and commonalities of brain processing in VR reveals limitations and holds important implications for VR therapy and training tools. When VR therapy aims at the rehabilitation of brain function and activity, differences in brain processing have to be taken into account for designing effective VR training tools. Furthermore, for an evaluation of possible restoration effects caused by VR training, it is necessary to integrate information about the brain activation networks elicited by the training. The present study provides an example for demonstrating the benefit of fMRI as an evaluation tool for the mental processes involved in virtual environments.

Current trends in stroke rehabilitation. A review with focus on brain plasticity

“…VR spatial brain processing differs from brain fMRI activation in reality. Thus, in evaluation of possible restoration effects caused by VR training it is important to integrate information about the brain activation networks elicited by the training (110). Tele-rehabilitation that allows a therapist to conduct interactive VE treatment sessions with a patient who is located at home has shown highly significant results in three standard clinical tests after 30 l-h sessions, maintained at 4-month follow-up (111).…”

Building virtual reality fMRI paradigms: A framework for presenting immersive virtual environments

“…Other VR stimulus systems use several components from third companies as well. In particular, the software 3DVIA, Corp., Virtools (Mellet et al, 2010) or the open source software ReactorMan (Beck et al, 2010) are often used for developing and presenting virtual environments.…”

Multisensory Stimulation in Stroke Rehabilitation

“…In evaluation of possible restoration effects caused by VR training it is therefore important to integrate information about the brain activation area networks elicited by the training in VR. Combining VR and fMRI in intact brains has confirmed differences and commonalities of brain processing in VR and demonstrated the benefit of fMRI as an evaluation tool for the mental processes involved in virtual environments (Beck et al, 2010). …”