Evaluation of Skin Irritation of Acids Commonly Used in Cleaners in 3D-Reconstructed Human Epidermis Model, KeraSkinTM

Abstract

Cleaners such as dishwashing liquids contain various chemicals that cause skin damage. Alkaline agents used in cleaners alter the lipid composition of the skin and damage the skin barrier. However, little is known about the effects of acids used in cleaners on the skin. Here, we investigated the effects of acidic pH on the skin and evaluated the skin irritation of acids commonly used in cleaners with a 3D-reconstructed human epidermis model, KeraSkinTM, according to OECD TG439. First, to examine the effects of acidic pH, we evaluated the skin irritation of citrate buffers (0.1 M, McIlvaine buffer) prepared in a wide pH range (pH 1.5–6.0). Surprisingly, cell viability was not significantly affected even at pH 1.5, reflecting that the acidity alone may not be sufficient to induce skin irritation. Even after longer exposure (180 min), the cell viability was not reduced below 50%, a cutoff to determine an irritant. To examine the effect of the anionic part, several organic acids used in cleaners (citric acid, glycolic acid, lactic acid, malic acid, and succinic acid) were examined. These organic acids also failed to reduce viability at 0.1 M. However, at 1 M, most of the acids tested, except lactic acid, were determined to be skin irritants. Histology further supported the skin irritancy of acids at 1 M. Similarly, inorganic acids (hydrogen bromide, hydrogen chloride, nitric acid, and sulfuric acid) were determined to be irritants only at 1 M. In the case of alkaline agents, pH and concentrations were also important factors to determine the skin irritancy, although the epidermal structure and lipids were more damaged than acids. Collectively, we demonstrated that both the pH and concentration are important factors for the skin irritancy of acids, shedding an important insight into the mechanism of skin irritation.

Does green mean clean? Volatile organic emissions from regular versus green cleaning products

“…Lactic acid is used in the green cleaning industry as a descaling and antimicrobial agent, which is produced by fermentation based on natural and renewable resources, and is an alternative to synthetic agents such as inorganic acids. 50…”

The influence of anionic and nonionic surfactants on the usage properties of heavy duty cleaners

“…The irritating potential of succinic acid as potential ingredient of cleaners has been studied by Hwang et al (2022). The test of skin irritation in 3D-reconstructed human epidermis model shown that exposition to succinic acid at the concentration of 0.1 mol/dm 3 caused no significant decrease in cell viability.…”

Comparison of structural characteristics and molecular markers of rabbit skin, pig skin, and reconstructed human epidermis for an ex vivo human skin model

“…In particular, the stratum corneum is the key to maintaining skin barrier function and xenobiotic metabolism [ 17 ]. Accordingly, the structural integrity of the stratum corneum is closely linked to resistance to skin irritation [ 18 ] and the development of skin diseases [ 19 ]. The epidermis of RHE [ 14 ] and ex vivo skin models from animals consists of the same epidermal layers as found in humans [ 20 ].…”