Evaluation of RANS-DEM and LES-DEM Methods in OpenFOAM for Simulation of Particle-Laden Turbulent Flows

Abstract

CFD-DEM modelling of particle-laden turbulent flow is challenging in terms of the required and obtained CFD resolution, heavy DEM computations, and the limitations of the method. Here, we assess the efficiency of a particle-tracking solver in OpenFOAM with RANS-DEM and LES-DEM approaches under the unresolved CFD-DEM framework. Furthermore, we investigate aspects of the unresolved CFD-DEM method with regard to the coupling regime, particle boundary condition and turbulence modelling. Applying one-way and two-way coupling to our RANS-DEM simulations demonstrates that it is sufficient to include one-way coupling when the particle concentration is small (O ~ 10−5). Moreover, our study suggests an approach to estimate the particle boundary condition for cases when data is unavailable. In contrast to what has been previously reported for the adopted case, our RANS-DEM results demonstrate that simple dispersion models considerably underpredict particle dispersion and previously observed reasonable particle dispersion were due to an error in the numerical setup rather than the used dispersion model claiming to include turbulence effects on particle trajectories. LES-DEM may restrict extreme mesh refinement, and, under such scenarios, dynamic LES turbulence models seem to overcome the poor performance of static LES turbulence models. Sub-grade scale effects cannot be neglected when using coarse mesh resolution in LES-DEM and must be recovered with efficient modelling approaches to predict accurate particle dispersion.

RETRACTED: Influence of indoor relative humidity on the number concentration, size distribution, and trajectory of sneeze droplets: Effects on social distancing guidelines

“…Typically, the Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS), Large Eddy Simulation (LES), and Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes equation (RANS) with turbulence models (i.e., standard, realizable, and renormalization group (RNG) k - ε and k - ω models) were used for generating the mean airflow velocity conditions and including cough and sneezing airflows ( Vuorinen et al, 2020 ; Feng et al, 2020 ; Zeng et al, 2021 ; Rosti et al, 2021 ; Jaiswal et al, 2022 ; Olivieri et al, 2022 ). RANS approach evaluates the mean turbulent flow motion.…”

On the process of fine sediment infiltration into static gravel bed: A CFD–DEM modelling perspective

“…As DNS and LES resolve flow beyond mean flow fields and eventually would result in a more accurate estimation of fluid–particle interaction terms. The DNS–DEM or LES–DEM is mostly not possible, especially for particles larger than typically resolved flow fields (Jaiswal et al, 2022). One has to compromise with the coarsely resolved flow fields, such as mean flow fields, resolved with the RANS approach, especially dealing with large particles such as gravel and sand.…”

“…One has to compromise with the coarsely resolved flow fields, such as mean flow fields, resolved with the RANS approach, especially dealing with large particles such as gravel and sand. The RANS–DEM approach neglects the effects of turbulent fluctuations on the particle's trajectory and additional dispersion models would be required to recover the lost turbulent fluctuations due to RANS averaging (Bocksell & Loth, 2006; Jaiswal et al, 2022; Loth, 2000; Minier et al, 2014). However, the inclusion of the dispersion model should be decided based on the process under consideration and might not be necessary.…”

Study on deformation of tunnel pile foundation based on discrete element method and finite difference method

“…The simulation results show that the numerical model based on DEM-FDM coupling can reasonably simulate tunnel shield tunneling under the condition of TBM operation, and has good robustness. Consequently, more and more research has based on DEM-FDM coupling method [ 28 – 30 ]. Qu et al [ 31 ] established a computational model using the coupled DEM-FDM method and realized the simulation of the whole process of shield construction.…”