Evaluation of Psychometric and Linguistic Properties of the Italian Adolescent Pain Assessment Scales: A Systematic Review

Abstract

IntroductionAdolescents’ pain experiences are complex and multidimensional, and evaluating pain only from a sensory and affective point of view may be in many instances limiting and inadequate; this is the reason why it is of paramount importance to identify the tools which can better assess the pain experienced by young patients. A person-oriented approach is highly encouraged, as it may better investigate the cognitive and behavioral development typical of this age group. The aim of this review paper is to describe the available tools which are able to adequately assess pain intensity in adolescents, in particular those validated in Italian.MethodsWe conducted a systematic review using four databases: CINAHL, PsycINFO, PubMed and Cochrane, and selected all the articles published between January 1970 and November 2017. We selected all the papers reporting the validation process of pain assessment tools specifically tailored for adolescent patients (age range 10–18 years) and based on psychometric and linguistic parameters, and focused especially on the tools available in Italian and able to measure acute and chronic pain.ResultsThe results of our investigation have revealed the existence of 40 eligible tools, 17 of which are monodimensional and the remaining 23 multidimensional, more specifically tailored to assess both acute and chronic pain. Some of the instruments (26) were self-reports while others were classified as behavioral (13) and/or mixed. Only one tool turned out to be suitable for fragile adolescents, while six adopted a person-oriented approach that better emphasized the cognitive and behavioral process typical of the adolescent population. None of them has ever been validated in Italian.ConclusionValid and reliable psychometric tools specifically organized to provide a cultural and linguistic evaluation of the patient are indeed the most recommended instruments to assess the intensity of the pain experienced by the patient, as they may provide useful information to implement a health policy aimed at identifying the best assistance programs.

Validity And Reliability of The Full Cup Test In Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain

“…[20] In a review investigating the pain scales among adolescents from Italy in 2018, FCT was depicted to be an applicable test over 7 years. [21] While there are studies on feasibility of the FCT on adult population, studies regarding pediatric patients are required.…”

Educational Intervention to Strengthen Pediatric Postoperative Pain Management: A Cluster Randomized Trial

“…The general principles of pain management in children include regular pain assessments, which should be made throughout the course of treatment (3,31) and which should include self-reports whenever possible (3). Several pain assessment tools can be used to assess children: behavioral scales (e.g., the Face, Legs, Activity, Cry, Consolability Scale [FLACC]), face scales (e.g., the Faces Pain Scale-Revised [FPS-R]), and numerical scales (e.g., the Numerical Rating Scale [NRS]) (32)(33)(34). However, no single tool is suitable for children of all ages (35,36).…”