Evaluation of Professional Development in the Use of Arts-Integrated Activities with Mathematics Content: Findings About Program Implementation

Abstract

In 2010, the Wolf Trap Foundation for the Performing Arts, Institute for Early Learning Through the Arts, was awarded an Arts in Education Model Development and Dissemination (AEMDD) grant to develop, implement, and disseminate a research-based program of professional development (PD) that equips prekindergarten and kindergarten teachers to infuse mathematics instruction with arts instruction in their classrooms. The PD includes summer institutes and classroom-based residencies in which music, dance, and drama performing artists work with teachers in teams. This instructional approach is often called arts integration. American Institutes for Research (AIR) conducted an evaluation of the four-year grant from 2010-2014, examining the implementation of the PD and assessing its impact on teacher practices and student mathematics knowledge. This article reports on the experiences of the elementary school teachers and Wolf Trap teaching artists in the first cohort of participating schools during 2011-12 and 2012-13, drawing on data from a variety of sources (PD observations, residency artifacts, artist interviews, and teacher surveys). We find that the Wolf Trap PD program demonstrates features of effective PD. It is classroom-based, intensive, and focused on what teachers and students need to know to teach and learn mathematics. It is aligned with district standards and offers many opportunities to teachers for active learning. The Wolf Trap PD program delivered preparation to teachers to infuse performing arts-based strategies into their mathematics instruction, starting in the PD institutes and then continuing in the residencies and did so with fidelity to the planned model. Wolf Trap used several approaches to optimize fidelity: a planning year and practice sessions with teaching artists, consistent use of local content experts, and materials structured to reflect the concepts and approaches used in both institutes and residencies. The article concludes with suggestions for practitioners and questions for further research.

Coaching early childhood teachers: A systematic review of its effects on teacher instruction and child development

“…Based on the analysis of coaching procedure, we found two ways of coaching: on‐site coaching ( N = 24, 72.7%) and web‐mediated coaching (or distance coaching, N = 8, 24.2%). Details of the coaching procedure in two studies were unavailable (i.e., Ludwig & Song, 2015; Raver et al, 2008).…”

“…In Landry et al's (2006) Academic skills Ludwig and Song's (2015) intervention study indicated that the coaching programme had significant positive impact on children's mathematics attainment in the first and the second year of implementation. The positive effect of coaching on children's academic skills should also be linked to their language skills and self-regulation, which are particularly sensitive to teaching quality (Pianta et al, 2017).…”

Creative and Body-based Learning: Redesigning Pedagogies in Mathematics

“…Arts-based pedagogies use one or more art forms to stimulate creative processes and deepen understanding in non-arts learning (Lee, Cawthon & Dawson, 2013;Ludwig & Song, 2014). Integration of a range of disciplines with the arts has been shown to have powerful effects on learning.…”

Nursing Students and the Human Body: Application of an Ethics Pilot Project

“…By engaging in experiences that enhance nurses’ awareness of the body’s role in the self, nurses will be better prepared to mindfully care for clients [ 3 , 4 , 20 ]. An arts-integrated pedagogy is a holistic learning approach that incorporates the intersection between the nature (environment) and the embodied practice of the human body, mind, and emotions [ 21 , 22 , 23 ].…”