Evaluation of Methodologies in Benefit–Cost and Economic Impact Analyses for Freight Rail Projects

Abstract

Public investment in privately owned freight rail infrastructure is mutually beneficial if that investment benefits the public. Public–private partnerships are emerging as a viable procurement method to leverage public and private funding or financing in transportation projects to meet the mobility needs of an expanding economy. This paper summarizes the research conducted as part of a larger project to evaluate the state of the practice in methodologies that estimate the benefits generated by freight rail projects. The research examined existing research, case studies, and benefit–cost analyses and economic impact analyses of implemented, approved, and proposed rail projects. Much variation was found in the approaches, definitions, techniques, and level of detail employed. The research defined and characterized projects, developed a generalized benefit classification scheme, and analyzed and evaluated data sources, methodologies, and assumptions on which quantification and monetization of projected benefits were based. The paper draws conclusions about—and recommends improvements in—approaches and methodologies to allow more objective comparisons among projects, with a focus on the parameters underlying the calculation of benefits and performance measurement after the project is completed.

Performance Measurement and Evaluation of Public-Private Partnerships: A Systematic Literature Review

“…Wang D, et al [22] -Look beyond contract terms to properly understand and manage PPP performance Klijn EH, et al [33] -PPP Contractual structure Gordon C, et al [38] -PPC-based metrics and performance indicators Tijssen RJW, et al [43] -Model of performance measurement that accurately evaluates the complete and comprehensive PPP Grossman SA, et al [41] -Methodologies that estimate the benefits generated by freight rail projects Protopapas A, et al [42] -Analytical framework assessing PPPs Forrer J, et al [47] Source: Own elaboration.…”

Evaluation of Rail Infrastructure Investments Related to the New Rail Regulatory Environment in Some Countries

“…Apart from assessing the difference between the carbon emissions of trucks and trains, the study failed to provide a comprehensive ex ante evaluation of investment in rail infrastructure. Another study examined the existing research, case studies, cost-benefit analyses, and economic impact analyses of implemented, approved, and proposed rail projects (8). Considerable variation was found in the approaches, definitions, techniques, and level of detail employed.…”