Evaluation of Different Approaches To Assess the Surface Tension of Low-Energy Solids by Means of Contact Angle Measurements

Abstract

Assessment of the surface tension of low-energy solids by means of easy to perform contact angle measurements would be very attractive. Two different approaches are frequently reported to be very promising in this respect. We have evaluated these approaches using mainly apolar surfaces, which present the simplest case possible. The "equation of state" approach, which uses a single parameter, correctly predicts the results on FC722 (perfluoropolyacrylate) and FEP (poly(tetrafluoroethylene-cohexafluoropropylene)), but shows systematic deviations on the surfaces of octyltrichlorosilane (self-assembled on glass) and PE (polyethylene). The "surface tension components" approach uses three parameters. The surface tension is split into a van der Waals component, a Lewis acid component, and a Lewis base component. The determination of the surface tension of apolar surfaces yields reasonably consistent results when using a large set of contact angle data. However, the present results indicate important differences with previously reported values of the van der Waals components of some fluids, i.e., dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), formamide, diiodomethane, and 1-bromonaphthalene. The latter two appear not to be apolar in nature when obtained from measurements on FC722 or FEP. The difference with previous reports is due to a discrepancy between the contact angles of diiodomethane and 1-bromonaphthalene measured on either FC722 or PE. It is concluded that neither the "equation of state" nor the "surface tension components" approach can account for all experimental results. The present use of contact angle measurements appears to be limited to the estimation of the surface tension of apolar surfaces, using the "surface tension components" approach.

Literature review on superhydrophobic self‐cleaning surfaces produced by electrospinning

“…16 When the contact angle for liquid is higher than 20 , it can be assumed that c SV % c S and c LV % c L . 17 cos…”

Solubility and adhesion characteristics of plasma polymerized thin films derived from Lavandula angustifolia essential oil

“…As such, there have been many publications addressing the validity of the methods, [24][25][26][27][28] accuracy, 29 and reviews of the available methods. 30,31 For this study, three approaches were chosen to provide a basis of comparison: the VCG approach, the EOS approach, and the Fowkes approach. 32 …”

CNT-Based Inherent Sensing and Interfacial Properties of Glass Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composites

“…The adhesive strength of an interface depends on the thermodynamic work of adhesion which, in a fiber-reinforced composite, is closely related to the surface energy between fibers and matrix [19]. The macroscopic Young-Dupre equation correlates the contact angle to the surface and interfacial tensions, which may be further decomposed into Lifshitz-van der Waals (LW) and the polar components of the surface energies [20]. Different routes of surface energy analyze have been outlined by Zisman.…”