Evaluation of a Performance Index for Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants using MCDM – TOPSIS

Abstract

Deciding which are the best performing wastewater treatment plants can be complicated, as their operations comprise different parameters which are either dependent or non-dependent on each other, and are important when deciding the type of treatment. The relative importance of these parameters in terms of weight indicates the priority assigned by decision-makers to the criteria when ranking the alternatives. These weights are calculated by statistical relativity and Saaty's nine point scale. The sensitivity of both of these approaches is analyzed. The performance of six municipal wastewater treatment plants is evaluated using the Multi-criteria Decision Making (MCDM) Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS). Efficiency is monitored on the basis of nine wastewater characteristics and compared with the limits established by the Central Pollution Control Board of India. The analysis uses both qualitative and quantitative approaches, which result in differential rankings; accordingly, plants with maximum organic loading removal efficiency were found to be most efficient when weights were applied as per Saaty's scale. The study proposes a field base approach with regard to the suitability of the weight allocation method for respective utilization of the fuzzy approach in environmental monitoring systems.

Predicting Biogasification Potential of Urban Wastewater Using Multiparameter Aggregated Index of Influent

“…Opinions of the expert from different professions like academic, environment, etc., were considered while assigning the weights by decision maker [40]. Weights were assigned on the basis of the nine-point scale set by Saaty [41][42][43][44][45][46]; as summarized in Table 4.…”

Wastewater treatment technology selection using a hybrid multicriteria decision‐making method

“…Anaokar et al. (2018) evaluated the performance of six Indian urban WWT plants according to an environmental criterion by utilizing the fuzzy TOPSIS method. For the weight allocation, two approaches were used: statistical regression and correlation and Saaty's 9‐point scale in a pairwise comparison matrix.…”

An Integrated Approach for Supplier Evaluation and Selection using the Delphi Method and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): A New Framework

“…The multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) approach is a decision aid framework that can evaluate multiple conflicting criteria (Shukor et al, 2018). It is a method of operational research in which various criteria are included in decision-making conditions to give optimal solutions (Anaokar et al, 2018). MCDM looks at the paradigm in which an individual decision-maker or a group of experts contemplate a choice of action in an uncertain environment.…”