Evaluating assertions by a Wells Fargo CEO of a ‘return to ethical conduct’

Abstract

We explore the language used by the CEO of Wells Fargo, Timothy Sloan, to sustain claims that Wells Fargo and its staff would behave in an ethically appropriate way in the future. We focus on Sloan’s opening written statement to the Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs of the United States Senate on 3 October 2017. This statement was intended to salvage Wells Fargo’s reputation after it had been savaged by widespread allegations of unethical conduct. Sloan sought to display ethical leadership by drawing the senators’ and other stakeholders’ attention to an (alleged) epiphany in the managerial mindset of the company. This paper contributes by proposing three desirable hallmarks by which to analyze claims of ethical leadership: balanced framing, principled use of ideology and metaphor, and justified rhetoric. These hallmarks are then explored to assess the ethical leadership discourse in Sloan’s statement. The paper demonstrates that analysis of the micro discourse of a CEO can reveal lack of a sound appreciation of the human complexity of a large organization, superficial assumptions of leadership and followership, and cloud the location of agency for ethical lapses. We conclude that the written statement submitted to the senate committee by CEO Sloan was unconvincing in enlisting belief that Wells Fargo would ‘return to ethical conduct’.

Creating Sustainable Business Stakeholder Ecosystems and a Healthy Green Circular Economy: Examining Multigenerational Individual and Organizational Perspectives, Entrepreneurship and Innovation, and Research Discussions Throughout the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…The organization created a quota system and incentive-based performance pay for exceeding sales goals. In terms of previous research highlights, several evidences of ethical misconduct and lack of moral awareness and individual accountability showed how Wells Fargo leaders and executives offered unethical instructions to their employees on how to exaggerate their sales numbers to reach the targets (Amernic, & Craig, 2022;Mitchell, Reynolds, & Treviño, 2017;Tayan, 2019). Employees opened new credit and bank accounts for existing customers without customer knowledge or consent.…”

“…The creation of these new accounts satisfied the sales targets and resulted in bonus payments to the employees. When the practice was discovered and made public, the trust with the public was lost (Amernic & Craig, 2022;Tayan, 2019).…”

Does CEO narcissism matter? An examination of the relationship between board structure and earnings management in Kenya

“…Although there are several traits, we focus on narcissisma trait that has been found to influence CEO's decision-making (Petrenko et al, 2016;Ham et al, 2018). A growing body of evidence suggests that firms led by narcissistic CEOs suffer significant disadvantages (Chatterjee and Hambrick, 2007;Ham et al, 2018;Rijsenbilt and Commandeur, 2017) because such CEOs are self-centered, domineering, have unyielding arrogance, engage in ego-defensive behavior and avoid failures in what they do in order to preserve their reputation or possibly boost performance-based compensation (Amernic and Craig, 2022;Ham et al, 2017).…”

Discretionary Accounting Narratives in Contemporary Corporate Reporting: Review and Framework

“…This constitutes an attempt by the script authors "to control the way in which the corporate story is interpreted" (p. 199). In this vein, various studies demonstrate how corporate leaders use discretionary accounting narratives to imprint their view of reality and thus control outsiders' perceptions of the firm (e.g., Amernic & Craig, 2022;Craig & Amernic, 2021).…”