EU democracy promotion in the neighbourhood: from leverage to governance?

Abstract

EU external democracy promotion has traditionally been based on 'linkage', i.e. bottom-up support for democratic forces in third countries, and 'leverage', i.e. the top-down inducement of political elites towards democratic reforms through political conditionality. The advent of the European Neighbourhood Policy and new forms of association have introduced a new, third model of democracy promotion which rests in functional cooperation between administrations. This article comparatively defines and explicates these three models of external democracy promotion. It argues that while 'linkage' has hitherto failed to produce tangible outcomes, and the success of 'leverage' has basically been tied to an EU membership perspective, the 'governance' model of democracy promotion bears greater potential beyond the circle of candidate countries. In contrast to the two traditional models, however, the governance approach does not tackle the core institutions of the political system as such, but promotes transparency, accountability, and participation at the level of state administration.

Leverage and linkage: how regionalism shapes regime dynamics in Africa

“…The concept of linkage has been discussed with broader understandings in the democratisation literature both with regard to transnational coalitions (Schmitz 2006) and the socialisation of elites through membership or the prospect of membership (Lavenex and Schimmelfennig 2011). According to Levitsky and Way, linkage is supposed to contribute to democratisation in three ways: by heightening the international reverberation caused by autocratic abuse, by creating domestic constituencies for norm-abiding behaviour, and by reshaping the domestic distribution of power and resources (Levitsky and Way 2010, pp.…”

The good, the bad, and the ambitious: democracy and autocracy promoters competing in Belarus

“…Retrieved 20 September 2014 from http://aei.pitt.edu/1802/1/democracy_-declaration_1991.pdf. 7For an overview on instruments and strategies for democracy promotion of the EU, see, for example,Schimmelfennig and Scholtz (2008),Knodt et al (2011), andLavenex and Schimmelfennig (2011).198 K A T S I A R Y N A Y A K O U C H Y K…”

Too good to be true? United Nations peacebuilding and the democratization of war-torn states

“…That is, the overall effect of a UN mission deployment on democratization would again be underestimated if this potential cofounder was not factored in. Secondly, several scholars hypothesize that a democratic neighborhood can foster transitions to democracy by transmitting norms and diffusing pro-democratic ideas Way, 2006, 2010;Teorell, 2010; and with reference to Europe: Barbe´et al, 2009;Bo¨rzel, 2011;Lavenex and Schimmelfennig, 2011).…”