Etiology, Pathophysiology and Mortality of Shock in Children in Low (Middle) Income Countries: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Objectives Shock is a life-threatening condition in children in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC), with several controversies. This systematic review summarizes the etiology, pathophysiology and mortality of shock in children in LMIC. Methods We searched for studies reporting on children with shock in LMIC in PubMed, Embase and through snowballing (up to 1 October 2019). Studies conducted in LMIC that reported on shock in children (1 month–18 years) were included. We excluded studies only containing data on neonates, cardiac surgery patients or iatrogenic causes. We presented prevalence data, pooled mortality estimates and conducted subgroup analyses per definition, region and disease. Etiology and pathophysiology data were systematically collected. Results We identified 959 studies and included 59 studies of which six primarily studied shock. Definitions used for shock were classified into five groups. Prevalence of shock ranged from 1.5% in a pediatric hospital population to 44.3% in critically ill children. Pooled mortality estimates ranged between 3.9-33.3% for the five definition groups. Important etiologies included gastroenteritis, sepsis, malaria and severe anemia, which often coincided. The pathophysiology was poorly studied but suggests that in addition to hypovolemia, dissociative and cardiogenic shock are common in LMIC. Conclusions Shock is associated with high mortality in hospitalized children in LMIC. Despite the importance few studies investigated shock and as a consequence limited data on etiology and pathophysiology of shock is available. A uniform bedside definition may help boost future studies unravelling shock etiology and pathophysiology in LMIC.

Prevalence, mortality, and aetiology of paediatric shock in a tertiary hospital in Malawi: A cohort study

“…A possible explanation could be prior antibiotic administration which may have lowered prevalence of bacteraemia in our population. The organisms we found are in line with prior research from African settings [ 17 , 18 ].…”

Global Emergency Medicine: A Scoping Review of the Literature from 2022

“…highlighted significant disparities in access to trauma care within and across sub‐Saharan African countries, but there are significant gaps in trauma‐specific data, as evidenced by the fact that less than half of countries were represented in the review. Assies et al 43 . reviewed 959 studies from LMICs and found that the etiology, pathophysiology, and mortality trends of shock are still poorly understood, most likely as a result of heterogenous definitions of shock in different contexts.…”

Usefulness of Non-Invasive Parameters (Inferior Vena Cava Diameter, Inferior Vena Cava Collapsibility, Inferior Vena Cava-Aortic Ratio) for Hemodynamic Monitoring in Critically Ill Children: A Systematic Review

“…The prevalence of shock is ranging from 1.5% in hospitalized children, to 44.3% in critically ill children. 1 When left untreated or detected late, hypovolemic condition could be fatal and might cause death. Early detection and correction of hypovolemia can restrict hypoxic damage, relieve tissue hypoxia, enhance the clinical outcome of critically ill patients, and thus, might save the patient's life.…”