Ethnicity recording in health and social care data collections in Ireland: where and how is it measured and what is it used for?

Abstract

BackgroundIn the European Union (EU), discrimination based on racial and ethnic origin is prohibited under the Racial Equality Directive. Ireland is one of only three EU countries where a legal duty of equality data collection is placed on public bodies. It provides an important context in which to study ethnic equality monitoring; however no systematic mapping of where it occurs in health information systems has been carried out. The aim of this study is to identify all existing national health and social care data collections with information on ethnicity and to explore how this data has been collected and used.MethodsAn electronic search of a national catalogue of health and social care data collections (N = 97) was carried out to identify any collections which contained information on ethnicity. Data dictionaries were searched and key informants contacted. For each of the data collections that collected information on ethnicity, data was extracted on the ethnic categories used and how this data is collected; the completeness of ethnicity recording; and other measures related to ethnicity in the data collection. Relevant outputs for these data collections, related to ethnicity, were identified through key informants and electronic searches.ResultsOf the 97 data collections, 14 (14%) collected information on ethnic or cultural background. Country of birth was collected by 10 of these 14 data collections. Most used the ethnic categories in the Census and recommended that ethnicity should be self-identified and not assigned. Reported rates of identification were generally high (≥90%). Data collections which recorded ethnicity tended to be focused on potentially high-risk populations with no routine recording in primary care. There were some examples of where ethnic equality monitoring had informed targeted interventions e.g. vaccination awareness initiatives or cultural training for healthcare staff.ConclusionsDespite strong policy and legal imperatives, there is limited data collection of ethnicity in health and social care data collections in Ireland. While there are some examples of where differences by ethnicity have been identified and acted upon, a more coordinated and comprehensive approach to the collection, quality and utilization of ethnicity data is needed to promote health equity.

Developing the INCLUDE Ethnicity Framework—a tool to help trialists design trials that better reflect the communities they serve

“…How to go about recording ethnicity is not trivial. Those asking questions need to know why they are doing it and those being asked need to know how their ethnicity information will help to reduce inequalities [ 16 ]. The data need to be reported.…”

Using linked administrative health data for palliative and end of life care research in Ireland: potential and challenges

“…Data linkage to death certificate data, HIPE data and PCRS data should be feasible. The cystic fibrosis registry is unique among the datasets described here in that it collects ethnicity data 54 .…”

‘If relevant, yes; if not, no’: General practitioner (GP) users and GP perceptions about asking ethnicity questions in Irish general practice: A qualitative analysis using Normalization Process Theory

“…Fears among GP users and GPs about data being collected and not being used appropriately have been documented in other countries [ 32 ]. There is evidence of a problematic pattern of data under-use in Ireland [ 20 ]. One of the principles of GDPR, data minimization, requires that only data that are needed are collected, so collecting data and then not using them undermines this principle.…”

“…Ethnic identity is recorded in only 14 of 97 (14%) national health and social care data collections. Ethnicity is collected in psychiatric hospitals, drug and alcohol treatment centres and for some infectious disease notifications [ 20 ], but there is no routine data collection in primary care settings. While there is an increase in Irish research about migrant health, there has been little research on ethnicity data collection [ 18 ].…”