Ethical Preferences among Business Leaders: Implications for Business Schools

Abstract

Since 1976, the American Assembly of Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB) has encouraged business schools to include ethics in their curricula. Because lan guage is the means for conveying values, including ethical values, business com munication faculty play an important role in deciding what should be taught, and how. But until very recently, most researchers failed to look specifically at actual practices and perceptions in the workplace. To address that need, we conducted a survey of 250 business leaders concerning their ethical preferences and compared our results with an earlier study of business faculty and students. The survey, adapted from one used in the Arthur Andersen Business Ethics Program, consists of 20 narratives which presented respondents with the need to judge the impor tance of certain issues and their approval or disapproval of the action or decision described. We found no significant differences in responses to the 14 items which addressed ethical issues in such areas as creating health and environmental risks, taking credit when credit is not due, focusing on disability issues, deceiving cus tomers with products and services, and using insider information to gain personal advantage. We did find significant differences in responses to six narratives focused on ignoring wrongdoing in the workplace, doing special favors for others to gain personal advantage, and covering up flaws in merchandise or operations. Our results, and the survey instrument itself, provide useful tools for the business com munication classroom.

The Role of Hospitality Education in Women's Career Advancement: Responses From Students, Educators, and Industry Recruiters

“…The hospitality industry, specifically, involves critical ethical issues such as food sanitation, hotel security, and overbooking (Partlow & Woods, 1996). It is recommended that curriculum design require feedback from diverse stakeholders such as industry, employers, students, and other related parties (Conaway & Fernandez, 2000;Crane, 2004).…”

The Impact of Business Education on Moral Judgment Competence: An Empirical Study

“…What impact, positive or negative, has business education had? Although the AACSB has encouraged business schools to include ethics in their curricula as far back as 1976 (Conaway, 2000), and has considered recent recommendations to require ethics courses in the curricula for business schools seeking AACSB accreditation or re-accreditation (Swanson and Frederick, 2003), recent scandals in corporate America have raised serious doubts as to the quality and effectiveness of ethics instruction and how ethics has been integrated into business curricula. This research examines the impact that overall academic environment and teaching practices have in shaping everyday ethical decisions of future business leaders.…”

Using Student Generated Codes of Conduct in the Classroom to Reinforce Business Ethics Education

“…It provides students with the practice they will need in resolving conflicting values in the work place (Conaway and Fernandez, 2000;Neimark, 1995). In our analysis of those codes created mid-semester, it is apparent that codes of conduct are more relevant when there is conflict in the workgroup.…”

“…code of conduct, professional ethics and values, and a specific way of conducting business (Conaway and Fernandez, 2000;Delaney and Sockell, 1992;Financial Times, 1998;Malinowski and Berger, 1996;O'Boyle and Dawson, 1992;Shannon and Berl, 1997). This school would support specialized business ethics courses in functional areas (i.e.…”

“…The literature indicates that an undergraduate student will not only have to learn about ethics, but will need to be given an opportunity to practice ethical behavior. Conaway and Fernandez (2000) present the difference between ethics taught in the classroom and those practiced by business professionals. Park (1998) contends that effective business ethics education looks at individual values, societal norms, and organizational code of conduct (values).…”