Ethical Dilemmas Confronting Dentists in Queensland, Australia

Abstract

Background: This paper details contemporary ethical dilemmas encountered by Queensland dentists. Methods: An age-stratified sample of 499 dentists resident in Queensland was surveyed. The questionnaire contained scenarios of five common ethical dilemmas.In addition, open-ended questions sought the respondent's most frequent, difficult and recent ethical dilemmas, and where they would seek guidance in dealing with ethical problems. Results: Respondents acknowledged the patient's rights in treatment decisions and the dentist's right to refuse demands for inappropriate treatment. However, responses varied in the extent to which dentists may influence treatment decisions. Few respondents would ignore evidence of poor dental treatment but they are evenly divided in choosing to inform the patient, the dentist or both. Poor quality treatment is the most frequent and difficult dilemma, and half have experienced this problem recently. Requests by patients for fraudulent receipts occur in a third of responses. Dentists develop ethical values from multiple sources but for help with dental ethical problems, 90 per cent of respondents would consult another dentist. Conclusions: Of the ethical dilemmas discussed in this survey, those relating to poor quality treatment confronted most respondents. Also the actions of dentists in dealing with these dilemmas were most varied.

Complaints about dental practitioners: an analysis of 6 years of complaints about dentists, dental prosthetists, oral health therapists, dental therapists and dental hygienists in Australia

“…Given that 85% of dental practitioners work in the private sector, and that even insured patients may face high out of pocket costs, this result is not surprising. International commentary suggests that cost‐related concerns and over‐servicing are more common in fee‐for‐service systems, whereas under‐treatment tends to arise in capitated practices . Regardless of the cause, these findings raise important ethical issues for the dental profession insurers and government funders.…”

The Top 10 ethical challenges in dental practice in indian scenario: Dentist perspective

“…Empirical studies have shown that the physicians, dentists, and nurses have appreciated the importance of knowledge of ethics, but the majority of studies have shown poor knowledge of ethics and health law which has resulted in a violation of ethical principles. [ 3 14 15 16 17 18 19 ] Contrastingly, some of the studies have reported good to fair knowledge among dental professionals. [ 18 20 21 ]…”

“…[ 2 ] In the past few decades, the balance of decision-making in determining what is the “best” treatment has shifted from professional paternalism toward respecting the informed and autonomous decision of the patient. [ 3 ]…”

How much dentists are ethically concerned about overtreatment; a vignette-based survey in Switzerland

“…Planning and carrying out excessive treatment was one of the five factors Christensen offered on why the public’s attitude toward the credibility of dentists may be changing [ 36 ]. Overtreatment is also one aspect of the first broad category of ethical concern within the dental profession identified by the Queensland survey, that is, problems arising from the quality of care provided by other members of the profession, including under- and over-servicing and apparently substandard treatment [ 37 ].…”