Estimating Fracture Geometry in the Naturally Fractured Antrim Shale

Abstract

The Antrim Shale of the Michigan Basin has been an active gas play with over 3,500 wells drilled over the last 5 years. There is substantial evidence that the Antrim must be fracture stimulated to be economical and that two~stage treatments provide the best results. However, due to the shallow depths (500-2300 ft) and naturally fractured nature of the Antrim, fracture geometry is complex, and determination of optimal fracture treatments is not straight forward. Because historical field comparisons did not provide insight on the optimal fracture treatments, the Oas Research Institute (OR!) instituted a field~based project for the specific purpose of evaluating the geometry of hydraulic fractures in the Antrim.Open-and cased-hole tests were performed on two separate Antrim wells -a shallow producer (600 +/ft) and a deep producer (1550 +\-ft). Open-hole testing and data collection consisted of in-situ stress and mechanical property testing with Halliburton's THETM Tool (9 tests) and a detailed suite of geophysical logs including dipole sonic logs and natural fracture detection logs. Cased-hole testing consisted of preã nd post-fracture injection/falloff tests, minifracture treatments, multiple isotope tracer and tracer logs, and treating pressure and production data analysis.Analysis of open-and cased-hole data from the shallow and deep wells suggests that subvertical fractures are being created and are probably following existing natural fracture planes. The shallow depths, low in-situ stresses, and extremely fractured nature of the Antrim probably results in 343 the preferential opening of eXisting fractures instead of the creation of new fracture planes. As a result, the creation of multiple fractures and severe near wellbore tortuosity is likely. Therefore, the natural fractures are responsible for increased leakoff and will greatly impact created fracture geometry. The results also suggest that creating long propped hydraulic fractures in the Antrim is not likely due to the creation of mUltiple fractures.

Clearing the Waters of the Fracking Debate

“…Although Figure 1(a) is more accurate in its scaling and depiction of a cross-section of the geologic strata, it is true that not all gas wells occur this deep. For example, coal bed methane wells and parts of Michigan's Antrim shale are atypically shallow, with production occurring at depths of less than 1,000 feet below the surface (Hopkins et al 1995;Jenkins and Boyer 2008).…”

The Lewis Shale, San Juan Basin: What We Know Now

“…One possible explanation for this is that the hydraulic fracture propagates at an angle to the wellbore following existing natural fractures, but connects to the hydraulic fracture in adjacent intervals through the natural/hydraulic fracture network. 20 The spinner surveys on the SDWs were helpful in confirming the overall gas production rate from the Lewis. However, due to tool resolution combined with the relatively low flow rates, the flow data from the individual layers within the Lewis was usually not diagnostic.…”

Real-Time Pressure Diagnostics Used To Improve Pretreatment Frac Design: Case Studies in the Antrim Shale

“…Studies of open-and cased-holed data have shown the possibility of multiple fractures which possibly propagate horizontally or nonvertically, intersecting the wellbore parallel or with natural fractures. 4 The goal of performing an injection analysis real-time is not to ascertain the exact fracture geometry but to recognize the symptoms and be adequately equipped to counteract. Fig.…”