Estimating Animal Abundance in Ground Beef Batches Assayed with Molecular Markers

Abstract

Estimating animal abundance in industrial scale batches of ground meat is important for mapping meat products through the manufacturing process and for effectively tracing the finished product during a food safety recall. The processing of ground beef involves a potentially large number of animals from diverse sources in a single product batch, which produces a high heterogeneity in capture probability. In order to estimate animal abundance through DNA profiling of ground beef constituents, two parameter-based statistical models were developed for incidence data. Simulations were applied to evaluate the maximum likelihood estimate (MLE) of a joint likelihood function from multiple surveys, showing superiority in the presence of high capture heterogeneity with small sample sizes, or comparable estimation in the presence of low capture heterogeneity with a large sample size when compared to other existing models. Our model employs the full information on the pattern of the capture-recapture frequencies from multiple samples. We applied the proposed models to estimate animal abundance in six manufacturing beef batches, genotyped using 30 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers, from a large scale beef grinding facility. Results show that between 411∼1367 animals were present in six manufacturing beef batches. These estimates are informative as a reference for improving recall processes and tracing finished meat products back to source.

Distance and destination of retail meat alter multidrug resistant contamination in the United States food system

“…Among ground products, ground turkey products had an 8.5-fold greater prevalence of MDR bacterial contamination than ground beef. The additional grinding steps that incorporate hundreds of animals from different countries into a single batch of ground meat might contribute to an a larger prevalence of MDR bacterial contamination 43 – 47 .…”