Establishing world-class universities in China: deploying a quasi-experimental design to evaluate the net effects of Project 985

Abstract

The rapid advances of China's universities in major international league tables are generally believed to be an accomplishment of Project 985. A quasi-experimental study was, therefore, undertaken to test the belief and evaluate the effectiveness of this policy intervention, using 15-year panel data between 1998 and 2013. Results from a difference-indifferences model showed that Project 985 had a positive effect on publication outputs of '985' universities. Tier 2 '985' universities gained strong momentum in publication growth in international and ISI journals. Additionally, Theil index decomposition was employed to examine the stratification effect of Project 985. Results confirmed the homogenizing trend within '985' universities. In contrast, the vertical differentiation between '985' and '211' universities was noticeably enlarged. While sustained public funding is still vital, the study findings inform policy makers and HE leaders of greater sectorial and institutional reforms to fulfil individual HEI's needs and remove bottlenecks in publication growth.

The Russian University Excellence Initiative: Is It Really Excellence that Is Promoted?

“…They show that, in general, there is an increase in the number of publications in international journals after universities joined this program, but the publication activity of participants is significantly different. A more recent studу criticizes Zhang et al's methodology but confirms the publication growth, albeit finding a "homogenizing trend within 985 universities" (Zong and Zhang 2017). For many government university excellence programs, publication output is a key indicator of successful participation..…”

“…In addition, at this stage of the program, it is difficult to assess how the policy of global integration of Japanese universities will lead to qualitative improvements in the system. Zong and Zhang (2017) studying the Chinese project 985, also note that the publication gap between different types of universities is growing as a result of the excellence initiative.…”

The Russian Excellence Initiative for Higher Education: An Econometric Evaluation of Short-term Results

“…The study of Chinese universities participating in Project-985 by Zhang et al (2013) found that the rate of growth of publications for universities as a whole increased more quickly after the implementation of the ExIn. A quasi-experimental study based on DID conducted by Zong and Zhang (2017) to evaluate the effectiveness of Project-985, using 15-year panel data (1998-2013) also showed that the Project-985 had a positive effect on publication output of participating universities.…”

The Causal Impact Of Performance-Based Funding On University Performance: Quasi-Experimental Evidence From A Policy In Russian Higher Education

“…To establish causality between the increase in the amount of PBF and university performance in the subsequent periods, we employ the difference-in-differences (DID) estimator. This approach is widely used to evaluate the effect of the policy intervention by comparing the variation in an outcome variable over time between the treatment and the control group (Pedraja-Chaparro 2016; Zong and Zhang, 2019). Considering the obtainment of more resources from the government as a policy intervention (treatment), we calculate the effect of this increase on the set of performance indicators (outcome variables).…”