Establishing a health information workforce: innovation for low- and middle-income countries

Abstract

BackgroundTo address the shortage of health information personnel within Botswana, an innovative human resources approach was taken. University graduates without training or experience in health information or health sciences were hired and provided with on-the-job training and mentoring to create a new cadre of health worker: the district Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) Officer. This article describes the early outcomes, achievements, and challenges from this initiative.MethodsData were collected from the district M&E Officers over a 2-year period and included a skills assessment at baseline and 12 months, pre- and post-training tests, interviews during stakeholder site visits, a survey of achievements, focus group discussions, and an attrition assessment.ResultsAn average of 2.7 mentoring visits were conducted for M&E Officers in each district. There were five training sessions over 18 months. Knowledge scores significantly increased (p < 0.05) during the three trainings in which pre/post tests were administered. Over 1 year, there were significant improvements (p < 0.05) in self-rated skills related to computer literacy, checking data validity, implementing data quality procedures, using data to support program planning, proposing indicators, and writing M&E reports. Out of the 34 district M&E Officers interviewed during site visits, most were conducting facility visits to review data (27/34; 79%), comparing data sets over time (31/34; 91%), backing up data (32/34; 94%), and analyzing data (32/34; 94%). Common challenges included late facility reports (28/34; 82%), lack of transportation (22/34; 65%), inaccurate facility reports (10/34; 29%), and colleagues’ misunderstanding of M&E (10/34; 29%). Six posts were vacated in the first year (6/51; 12%). A total of 49 Officers completed the achievements survey; of these, common accomplishments related to improvements in data management (35/49; 71%), data quality (31/49; 63%), data use (29/49; 59%), and capacity development (26/49; 53%).ConclusionsThe development of a cadre of district M&E Officers has contributed positively to the health information system in Botswana. In the absence of tertiary training related to health information, on-the-job training and mentoring of university graduates can be an effective approach for developing a new professional cadre of M&E expertise and for strengthening capacity within a national health system.

Training Healthcare Workers on the Use of Electronic Medical Records in HIV clinics in Kenya: An Evaluation of Three Training Models

“…Studies by Luna et al and Ledikwe et al also indicate that trained staff are often poorly geographically distributed [2,8]. The decline in training costs, from $5,629 per trainee in Period 1 to $377 in Period 3, indicates that an on-site model can be less expensive to deliver, even in highly dispersed geographic settings.…”

“…Yet a number of recent studies have identified inadequate training in health informatics as a persistent barrier to the implementation of EMR in low-resource settings [2,7,8]. This lack of training includes low levels of computer literacy among clinical staff and a lack of appropriate training on point-of-care data entry and using EMR for clinical decision-making [7].…”

Analysis of the Acceptance Process of District Health Information Systems (DHIS) for Vertical Health Programmes: A Case Study of TB, HIV/AIDS and Malaria Programmes in Tanzania

“…Issues of human resource capacity for HIS in terms of both users and the implementation team (Sahay and Walsham, 2006) have to be considered when thinking of rolling out systems like DHIS. In Botswana, recruiting, providing on-job training and mentoring university graduates without training or experience in health information or health sciences proved to be beneficial in tackling the challenge of human resource for HIS through creating a non-existent cadre of monitoring and evaluation officers to work as personnel for HIS (Ledikwe et al, 2013).…”

Challenges and opportunities for effective adoption of HRH information systems in developing countries: national rollout of HRHIS and TIIS in Tanzania

“…Weak management of administrative HRH data on each of the stages of the working lifespan and weak analysis and utilization of HRH information to HRH policy and strategies were also pointed out [2]. Additionally, low competency of staff handling computerized information systems or insufficient competent workers to operate information systems were pointed at as being one of the major bottlenecks on sustainability of computerized information systems [2-4]. …”