We
have studied the electron-transfer photochromism of the crystalline
adducts of 4,4′-bipyridine (Bpy) and carboxylic acids and revealed
the key structural parameters that decide whether the photochromism
can happen for the first time. Experimental and theoretical analyses
on nine known examples showed that the hydrogen bonds, instead of
π–π stacking interactions, are the defining factor
to the photochromism. Only the presence of N–H···O
hydrogen bonds can fulfill the electron transfer from the carboxylate
group to the Bpy part, although both the N···O separations
of O–H···N and N–H···O
hydrogen bonds are suitable for the so-called through-space electron
transfer. These results can not only help to screen out the photochromic
species from the known hundreds of Bpy–carboxylic acid adducts
deposited in the Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre (CCDC) database
but also guide the design and syntheses of new adducts using diverse N-heterocyclic aromatic molecules and carboxylic acids.