Ab stractPurpose: The objective of this retrospective study was to compare the results of two operative techniques used for the treatment of distal radius fractures classified as AO type A3. Patients and Methods: Patients were treated with either fixed-angle volar plates or intrafocal Kirschner wires (K-wires) using a Kapandji-like technique. The functional results were determined with the Gartland & Werley Score as well as the DASH Score after an average follow-up of 28 months. Results: 55 patients were included in the study. Of these, 33 were female and 22 male, with an average age of 59 years. In patients < 60 years, the Gartland Score was 1.4 points in the fixed-angle volar plate group, and 4.6 points in the Kapandji group. In patients ≥ 60 years, no significant difference between the therapy groups could be ascertained. The DASH Score measured 17 points in each group. In all cases, a satisfactory reduction was obtained. The Kapandji group experienced significantly more loss of reduction position at follow-up in terms of volar tilt and radioulnar inclination than the fixed-angle volar plate group. Conclusion: These results show that intrafocal K-wire fixation in older patients is a suitable method to attain and hold sufficient bony reduction. However, younger patients achieve better radiologic and functional results when treated with open reduction using the 3.5-mm LCP fixed-angle volar plate.
Key Words
Radius fracture · K-wire · Fixed-angle plate
Eur J Trau ma 2005;31:44-50Introduction Type A3 fractures of the distal radius by the AO classification [18] are extraarticular fractures characterized by a comminuted zone of the metaphysis. Reduction and stable fixation of the fracture are complicated by this zone of dorsal comminution, and are even more difficult when a dorsal cortical defect exists [6]. The frequency of this fracture type is approximately 30% of all distal radius fractures [15]. As has previously been shown, simple cast immobilization in such fractures frequently leads to a secondary loss of reduction [27]. Fractures allowed to heal in a dorsally displaced malposition are related to unsatisfactory functional results [16]. The restoration of volar tilt and the avoidance of relative radial shortening (positive ulnar variance) are especially meaningful for the recovery of unrestricted wrist function [1,16].Intrafocal Kirscher wire (K-wire) fixation with the Kapandji technique [12] is a minimally invasive procedure. It has been shown that this method, used in the cases of unstable, dorsally displaced distal radius frac-