“…Many linguists do, in fact, analyze both (1a) and (2) as transitive clause types (Carrier-Duncan, 1985;Foley, 2008;Guilfoyle et al, 1992 1 ;Kroeger, 1993;Maclachlan, 1996Maclachlan, , 2002Paul and Travis, 2006;Rackowski, 2002;Rackowski and Richards, 2005;Schachter, 1976Schachter, , 1994. In this paper, I take a different tack.…”