Equity of access to primary healthcare for vulnerable populations: the IMPACT international online survey of innovations

Abstract

BackgroundImproving access to primary healthcare (PHC) for vulnerable populations is important for achieving health equity, yet this remains challenging. Evidence of effective interventions is rather limited and fragmented. We need to identify innovative ways to improve access to PHC for vulnerable populations, and to clarify which elements of health systems, organisations or services (supply-side dimensions of access) and abilities of patients or populations (demand-side dimensions of access) need to be strengthened to achieve transformative change. The work reported here was conducted as part of IMPACT (Innovative Models Promoting Access-to-Care Transformation), a 5-year Canadian-Australian research program aiming to identify, implement and trial best practice interventions to improve access to PHC for vulnerable populations. We undertook an environmental scan as a broad screening approach to identify the breadth of current innovations from the field.MethodsWe distributed a brief online survey to an international audience of PHC researchers, practitioners, policy makers and stakeholders using a combined email and social media approach. Respondents were invited to describe a program, service, approach or model of care that they considered innovative in helping vulnerable populations to get access to PHC. We used descriptive statistics to characterise the innovations and conducted a qualitative framework analysis to further examine the text describing each innovation.ResultsSeven hundred forty-four responses were recorded over a 6-week period. 240 unique examples of innovations originating from 14 countries were described, the majority from Canada and Australia. Most interventions targeted a diversity of population groups, were government funded and delivered in a community health, General Practice or outreach clinic setting. Interventions were mainly focused on the health sector and directed at organisational and/or system level determinants of access (supply-side). Few innovations were developed to enhance patients’ or populations’ abilities to access services (demand-side), and rarely did initiatives target both supply- and demand-side determinants of access.ConclusionsA wide range of innovations improving access to PHC were identified. The access framework was useful in uncovering the disparity between supply- and demand-side dimensions and pinpointing areas which could benefit from further attention to close the equity gap for vulnerable populations in accessing PHC services that correspond to their needs.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12939-016-0351-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Exploring levers and barriers to accessing primary care for marginalised groups and identifying their priorities for primary care provision: a participatory learning and action research study

“…Richard et al [54] suggested developing co-operative and participatory initiatives to achieve these goals. In this research we sought to do just that - using participatory methods to include the views of a variety marginalised patients on the factors influencing their access to health services.…”

Integrality of care for hemodialysis patient in Brazil: an analysis of access to dental care

“…Patients who had less formal education are normally associated with a lower income, which probably hinders access to dental care services since less financial resources are available for dental treatment and periodic consultations with dentists. Literature highlights that socioeconomic conditions are directly related to the frequency of recent consultations with dentists [18][19][20][21][22] .…”

“…As inequalities regarding access and utilization of health services have been identified, it is important to elaborate strategies and actions that improve access possible for people with lower income to public dental care services. Although innovative initiatives have been proposed, the inequalities do not present a decreasing rate over time 19,21,22 .…”

Special Health Care Utilization Pattern with Elevated Costs and High Risk of Premature Death Among Adults Living in Segregated Roma Settlements

“…In these circumstances, the necessary changes can be initiated neither in organization of health services nor in enhancing ability of Roma to use properly the health services [7]. Moreover, this problem hindering the elaboration of targeted interventions is reflected in the restricted effectiveness of programmes that aim at improvement of the health status of Roma people in European countries with significant Roma minorities.…”

“…Using these indicators, improvement in the effectiveness of the Roma projects is expected. The necessity of this kind of monitoring technology has been emphasized by the EU, the WHO, and national authorities, as well [5][6][7]10, 23].…”