Environments Past: Nostalgia in Environmental Policy and Governance

Abstract

A variety of factors shape environmental policy and governance (EPG) processes, from perceptions of physical ecology and profit motives to social justice and concerns with landscape aesthetics. Many scholars have examined the role of values in EPG, and demonstrated that attempts to incorporate (especially) non-market values into EPG are loaded with both practical and conceptual challenges. Nevertheless, it is clear that non-market values of all types play a crucial role in shaping EPG outcomes. In this article we explore the role of nostalgia as a factor in EPG. We examine literatures on environmental values, governance and affect in light of their relationships with environmental policymaking, first as a means to decide whether or not nostalgia can be rightly described as an 'environmental value'. We suggest that, from a philosophical perspective, nostalgia is by itself environmentally neutral, and is not usefully described as a 'value'. However, as an emotional state that longs to preserve or recover something of the past - whether fading or no longer present - that is fondly remembered, nostalgia does represent a potentially strong 'motivator' for EPG decisions. Despite this somewhat ambivalent assessment of nostalgia as an environmental value, we argue that nostalgia and nostalgic longing to return to 'better' or 'cleaner' environments can lead to potentially significant impacts on ecosystems and landscapes, both positive and negative depending on what it is that people want to preserve or restore. Thus we conclude that we neglect understanding the role of nostalgia in EPG at our peril: first, because preservationist goals have always been an important part of environmental responsibility; and second, because many people will be swayed regarding environmental action through a mobilisation of nostalgia by political leaders and interest groups alike. We end our article with suggestion of avenues for further empirical investigation.

Is poor mental health an unrecognised occupational health and safety hazard for conservation biologists and ecologists? Reported incidences, likely causes and possible solutions

“…The concept of solastalgia has struck a particular chord with many commentators, and the term appears in a range of research papers on the psychological responses of people to environmental change, usually degradation (e.g. Eisenman et al 2015;Askland and Bunn 2018;Galway et al 2019;Howell et al 2019).…”

Beyond Ecofascism? Far-Right Ecologism (FRE) as a Framework for Future Inquiries

“…This degree of confusion traverses across far-right discourse: although nostalgia is usually articulated in images of pristine nature and idyllic countryside, it also 'potentiates [an] attainable future' (Sedikides and Wildschut 2016, 319). Thus, moving beyond mere escapism, nostalgia is a proactive notion, deployed in various forms of environmental governance (Howell, Kitson and Clowney 2019).…”

Cultural Landscapes and Novel Ecosystems

“…There is a certain romanticism evident in much of conservation, whether it be from activists, scholars, practitioners, or politicians (Alagona et al 2012 ). This nostalgia is so strongly embedded into conservation that some have argued for its pre-eminence, even if the embrace of nostalgia is demonstrably at odds with the changing world (Higgs 2003 , 2012 ; Howell et al 2019 ).…”