Environmental upgrading of Third World enterprises through linkages to transnational corporations. Theoretical perspectives and preliminary evidence

Abstract

With economic globalization, Third World enterprises are increasingly collaborating with foreign firms through trade, subcontracting and equity linkages. The paper examines under which conditions linkages to foreign firms lead to environmental upgrading of Third World enterprises. Derived from the authors' research in a number of developing countries, the paper presents preliminary evidence of such upgrading. As the existing literature on environmental upgrading has a normative bias and tends to ignore economic mandates and constraints, the remaining part of the paper presents four theoretical frameworks based on standard business economics that may explain under which conditions linkages between Third World enterprises and foreign firms may be accompanied by environmental upgrading. It is argued that environmental upgrading in the value chain must be understood partly as a result of external industry and market forces, and partly as a result of the internal resources and competitive strategies of the companies involved. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment.

Corporate social responsibility in china: an analysis of domestic and foreign retailers' sustainability dimensions

“…A 2006 report of the ministry of commerce confirmed this better CSR by MNEs in China, which were said to have an impact on Chinese companies as well (Wei, 2006), sometimes via supply chains (cf. Jeppesen and Hansen, 2004). An example that came to the fore after the empirical study had been concluded is Wal-Mart's announcement to convene a meeting for around 1,000 Chinese suppliers to help increase their environmental performance (Birchall, 2008).…”

Innovation Capacity Evaluation Framework for Sustainable Value Chains

“…8.Green governance reforms: The environmental upgrading literature emphasizes the need for improvement in environmental performance beyond value chain upgrading (Jeppesen & Hansen, 2004). Accessing eco-innovation can help in solving environmental problems and gaining access to new technology for product and value chain upgrading in developing countries (Ockwell et al, 2010).…”

“…In addition, availability of environmental regulation, government support and forest sector policy (Bernauer, Engel, Kammerer, & Nogareda, 2006;Rennings, 2000); collaboration and interaction among institutions/actors;availability andacquisition of new technical knowledge; andpublic investment as well as market demand foster innovation processes in forestry (Kubeczko, Schaan & Anderson, 2002). Technical collaboration with foreign firms; monitoring and controlling; cross-functional collaboration and knowledge sharing; investment in new and clean technology; green skill development and training; development of a written environmental plan; development of environmental performance criteria; internal assessment of implementation of an environmental plan; implementation of certification and ISO 14001 standards; and extension of environmental criteria to the entire value chain are important processes for the adoption of greening practices (Darnall, Jolley, & Handfield, 2008;Jeppesen & Hansen, 2004). Existence of stakeholder dialogue and stakeholder knowledge integration, cultural and institutional development, public education, participatory environmental assessment and self-organization are key processes for changes in governing structures, efficient resource management, product stewardship and habitat preservation as well as for reducing pressure on natural resources (Berkes & Turner, 2006;Hart, 1995;Tabara & Pahl-Wastl, 2007).…”

Determinants of Environmental Management Transfer by Japanese Firms in Vietnam

“…Recent studies examine the transfer of knowledge and capabilities of MNEs (Gupta and Govindarajan,2000;Pèrez-Nordtvedt et al.2008;Fang et al, 2010). Jeppesen and Hansen (2004) summarized a number of approaches to developing countries enhancing the ability of their firms by building linkages with MNEs. First, the commodity chain approach indicates that products as a commodity is controlled through power balance between MNEs and developing countries.…”

“…The transfer of environmental management to developing countries will build first mover advantage to firms, and second, it in turn provides competitive advantage to suppliers as well (Jeppesen & Hansen, 2004). In contrast, the resource-based approach argues that resources and capabilities are the basis of growth and performance (Barney, 1991;Rugman & Verbeke, 1998).…”