Environmental influences on MNE subsidiary roles: economic integration and the Nordic countries

Abstract

We seek to examine the importance of environmental factors in determining MNE subsidiary roles. In particular, we examine the environmental factors associated with ‘deep’ integration schemes such as the EU. Such schemes require a convergence of economic structure, due to the establishment of common regional institutions, regulations and policies. Specifically, we distinguish between the scope of activities performed by subsidiaries, and the level of competence of those subsidiaries. The empirical analysis is based on a large-scale survey of foreign-owned units in Denmark, Finland and Norway. These Nordic countries differ with regard to their EU-membership status – Norway being the ‘outsider’, while the others are members – but are very similar to each other in most other respects. Our data show that subsidiaries in Norway report significantly lower scores for both scope of activities and levels of competence. The effects remain strong even when we are controlling for other potentially influential factors. The findings indicate that being on the ‘outside’ of the EU may indeed carry the price of becoming less attractive to MNE activity. Journal of International Business Studies (2003) 34, 443–456. doi:10.1057/palgrave.jibs.8400047

Foreign Direct Investment Through Acquisitions and Implications for Technological Upgrading: Case Evidence from Tanzania

“…That is to say, while MNE internal factors such as their internationalization strategy, the role of the new location in their global portfolio of subsidiaries, and the motivation of their investment are pivotal in the structure of their investment, all these issues are dependent on the available location-specific resources which can be used for that purpose. Indeed, the host country's location advantages play an important role in determining the level of embeddedness of the subsidiary (Benito et al 2003), and this is the primary determinant of the quality of the FDI. In some instances, MNEs may divest part of their operations because other subsidiaries in other countries within the MNE network are better positioned to perform these tasks.…”

“…MNEs sometimes seek to rationalise their operations on a regional or global basis, and therefore reduce (or increase) the intensity of operations of an acquired subsidiary by lowering the level of competence and/or scope of their subsidiary (Narula 2003). Thus, whether an acquired firm is upgraded or downgraded upon becoming a part of an MNE is not always clear, since it is a function of not just the competences and resources that are available to the MNE, but also the MNE's global or regional strategy and how the newly-acquired subsidiary fits into its existing structure (Benito et al 2003).…”

Determinants of Swiss Firms' R&D Activities at Foreign Locations: An Empirical Analysis Based on Firm-Level Data

“…In a second model, we determine the extent of foreign R&D expenditures, given the decision to perform or not perform R&D at foreign locations. In 1 Such a high degree of internationalisation of R&D is quite exceptional (see Benito, Grogaard, & Narula, 2003). 2 In this paper we do not deal with the intra-firm organisation of international R&D, i.e.…”

Strategies Pursued By Swiss Firms in Investing in R&D at Foreign Locations: An Empirical Analysis Based on Firm-Level Data

“…Foreign R&D is thus a means to complement and augment knowledge available at the domestic headquarter. In this case, knowledge-seeking (assetseeking) motives drive foreign R&D, what fits into the concept of the firm as proposed by evolutionary economics (see the "dynamic capability view of the firm" proposed by Teece and 1 Such a high degree of internationalisation of R&D is quite exceptional (see Benito et al, 2003). Pisano, 1998).…”