“…However, this scenario contradicts with the surface tension of NaOH solutions because the surface tension of NaOH solutions is larger than that of NaCl solutions, meaning Email address: uematsu@chem.kyushu-univ.jp (Yuki Uematsu) that OH − is more surface-inactive than Cl − [2,3,22]. Although other explanations were suggested [23,24], the experimental fact that the concentration and depth of the minima depend on independent measurements [6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13] implies uncontrolled hidden parameters in the experiments. Recently, one of the authors constructed the theory of the surface tension of electrolytes, and the Jones-Ray effect is explained by the traces of charged impurities in the water [22,25].…”