Environmental assessment of contrasted French organic vegetable farms

Abstract

French organic vegetable farms are diverse, ranging from complex biodiversity-based systems, with many vegetables, to simple input-based systems with few vegetables, suggesting potentially different impacts on the environment. We used life cycle assessment (LCA) to assess the impact of three contrasted farms: MF, a microfarm with a high crop diversity and a low input level, SP, a medium sized farm specialised in sheltered production with a low crop diversity and a high input level, and OP, a large farm specialised in outdoor production with intermediate input level and crop diversity. To cope with the complexity of organic vegetable farms, we opted for a system LCA, based on farm inputs and output for a one-year period. Using mass-, and area-based functional units, we analysed the impacts on climate change, land competition, biodiversity, and the use of plastic.Per ha, differences between the systems were large for climate change. SP had the highest impacts, whereas OP had the lowest impacts. Expressed per kg, differences between the systems for climate change were much smaller, even ranking differently. OP used much less plastic but performed worse on biodiversity and land competition. Despite its higher yield, SP did not perform better than other farms on impacts per kg for climate change, and plastic use. The impact on on-farm biodiversity, showed contrasting results compared to the other impacts. It highlighted the importance of semi-natural habitats. The quantification of plastic use echoed growing concerns on (micro-)plastic pollution in agricultural soils and landscapes.

Assessing the environmental impacts of conventional and organic scenarios of rainbow trout farming in France

“…Moreover, organic farming promotes fair relationships and a good quality of life for all involved (IFOAM, 2008). The magnitude of the benefits of organic farming can vary significantly depending on several factors, such as the farm-specific agricultural practices and management approaches, and local environmental conditions (Pépin et al, 2022; Smith et al, 2019). Thus, while organic farming generally fosters environmentally friendly practices, the actual environmental benefits can vary on a case-by-case basis (Meier et al, 2015).…”