Enhancing Traceability in Clinical Research Data through a Metadata Framework

Abstract

Background The clinical research data lifecycle, from data collection to analysis results, functions in silos that restrict traceability. Traceability is a requirement for regulated clinical research studies and an important attribute of nonregulated studies. Current clinical research software tools provide limited metadata traceability capabilities and are unable to query variables across all phases of the data lifecycle. Objectives To develop a metadata traceability framework that can help query and visualize traceability metadata, identify traceability gaps, and validate metadata traceability to improve data lineage and reproducibility within clinical research studies. Methods This research follows the design science research paradigm where the objective is to create and evaluate an information technology (IT) artifact that explicitly addresses an organizational problem or opportunity. The implementation and evaluation of the IT artifact demonstrate the feasibility of both the design process and the final designed product. Results We present Trace-XML, a metadata traceability framework that extends standard clinical research metadata models and adapts graph traversal algorithms to provide clinical research study traceability queries, validation, and visualization. Trace-XML was evaluated using analytical and qualitative methods. The analytical methods show that Trace-XML accurately and completely assesses metadata traceability within a clinical research study. A qualitative study used thematic analysis of interview data to show that Trace-XML adds utility to a researcher's ability to evaluate metadata traceability within a study. Conclusion Trace-XML benefits include features that (1) identify traceability gaps in clinical study metadata, (2) validate metadata traceability within a clinical study, and (3) query and visualize traceability metadata. The key themes that emerged from the qualitative evaluation affirm that Trace-XML adds utility to the task of creating and assessing end-to-end clinical research study traceability.

Statistical Enrichment Analysis of Samples: A General-Purpose Tool to Annotate Metadata Neighborhoods of Biological Samples

“…Systematic software platforms to organize large metadata and clinical data [also called “clinotype” ( Nguyen et al, 2021 )] is essential in biomedical research ( Burgun and Bodenreider, 2008 ; Ohmann and Kuchinke, 2009 ). These software platforms, such as ( Ta et al, 2018 ; Kim et al, 2019 ; Hume et al, 2020 ), have two key objectives. First, it allows the biomedical researcher to perform manual cohort selection quickly.…”

The Status of data management practices throughout the Data Life Cycle: a Mixed-Method Study across MIRACUM Data Integration Centers

“…We were interested to learn how organizational and document resources might help to generate metadata and to embed metadata within the digital object itself. Hume et al raised the importance of metadata development for traceability reasons [21]. Detailed results are available in an additional le [see additional le 4, Fig.…”

Standardized Integration of Person-Generated Data Into Routine Clinical Care

“…In addition to clinically relevant contextual information, use of PGD in health care or research also requires metadata [ 19 , 20 ]—data about the data. Examples include the name, model, and unique ID of the source device, and the unique ID of the app [ 21 ] installed on the patient’s smartphone that acquired the data.…”