Enhancing the collective, protecting the personal: the valuable role of composite narratives in medical education research

Abstract

Narrative research approaches provide the opportunity for constructing a detailed understanding of lived experiences relevant to medical education, in areas such as illness narratives, explorations of doctor-patient relationships, and the development of professional identities in students and educators. The benefits of the depth of data gathered in narrative research are, however, counterbalanced by possible weaknesses relating to a focus on individual cases and the risk of identification of participants where subjects are sensitive or unique. To address these concerns, researchers from a variety of social science disciplines, carrying out research employing a range of methodological approaches, have begun to use ‘composite narratives’ in which the commonalities in the experiences of research participants are combined to create joint narrative or narratives which illustrate participants’ shared experiences. Composite narratives have been used both as a component of the methodological approach and as a method of presenting the results of research in a variety of methodologies. This A Qualitative Space paper explores the role, strengths, and weaknesses of narrative research, before outlining the ways in which composite narrative has been defined within existing research. Distinctions between the various approaches to creating composite narratives are discussed, highlighting the differences in the types of data utilised, and the approaches taken to data analysis and presentation. A key distinction is identified between the use of composite narratives as part of an integrated methodology and as an approach to the presentation of data. Finally, issues relating to trustworthiness, reflexivity, and implications for researchers are considered.

Analysis of the role of “Online State Grid” in optimizing business environment and improving power supply service level

“…The systematic, forward-looking and effective planning of power grid is insufficient [7][8]. The power grid planning mainly focuses on solving the current problems, and the overall planning of the long-term target grid and regional power supply is insufficient; The planning of power grid has little guidance for power grid construction, and the project construction scheme has been greatly adjusted in the feasibility study; The power grid planning is a secret material, and planners at all levels do not know enough about the overall work situation, and have not formed a joint force to promote the work [9].…”

Identification of Structural Parameters of Offshore Platforms Based on Reality and Virtual Technology

“…where  h and  e represent the real signal and noise, respectively. Theoretically, the Hankel matrix H formed by the noisy signal in    h equation ( 1) can be divided into two parts [11][12] :…”

The power of animation: encouraging doctors to access support for psychological wellbeing

“…The storyboard is usually compiled directly from qualitative interview data and thus portrays real experiences. Compositive narratives are a useful method of presenting qualitative findings as they provide rich, authentic, detailed accounts while maintaining the anonymity of participants, as well as being a research output useable outside the academic community [22] and have been used in a variety of context [22] including medical education [23,24].…”