Proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) technology is an emerging and sustainable energy source with environmental and socioeconomic benefits. The performance of PEMFC technology mainly depends on the properties of the membrane. Therefore, it is an obligation to improve the membranes' properties, such as proton conductivity, ion exchange capacity, and thermal properties. In this paper, we have developed the hybrid membranes by suitably incorporating sulfonated functionalized nanosilica (SFnSi) into the sulfonated tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS)-crosslinked poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) matrix. The physicochemical properties of the resulting membranes were investigated using a Fourier transform infrared spectrometer, a wide-angle X-ray diffractometer, a scanning electron microscope and an atomic force microscope, a differential scanning calorimeter, and a thermogravimetric analyzer. The mechanical properties of the developed membranes were studied using a universal testing machine. The proton conductivity and the dielectric properties of the membranes were measured using a high-precision impedance analyzer. The water uptake, swelling ratio, and ion exchange capacity of the membranes were determined and discussed based on their molecular structures. Finally, the fuel cell performance was evaluated at 80 °C using a fuel cell workstation. Among the membranes developed, the 2 mass % SFnSi-incorporated hybrid membrane (SFnSi-2-sPVA/TEOS) exhibited the highest ion exchange capacity and proton conductivity of 2.5 meq/g and 1.56 S/cm at 80 °C, respectively. Similarly, the same membrane demonstrated the highest power density of 1.75 W/cm 2 at a current density of 1.92 A/cm 2 . From these results, it is ascertained that a trade-off phenomenon generally exists between proton conductivity and thermal stability, which is overcome by judiciously choosing and incorporating SFnSi into the sulfonated crosslinked PVA/TEOS membrane. Among the developed hybrid membranes, the membrane with 2 mass % SFnSi is much superior to the commercially available Nafion 117 and Nafion 212 membranes. Thus, the SFnSi-2-sPVA/TEOS hybrid membrane could be a potential candidate for fuel cell application.