Abstract:Nitrogen requirements for modern agriculture far exceed the levels of bioavailable nitrogen in most arable soils. As a result, the addition of nitrogen fertilizer is necessary to sustain productivity and yields, especially for cereal crops, the planet’s major calorie suppliers. Given the unsustainability of industrial fertilizer production and application, engineering biological nitrogen fixation directly at the roots of plants has been a grand challenge for biotechnology. Here we design and test a potentially… Show more
“…In a Δ glnE mutant of A. brasilense , controlled expression of a N-terminal truncated AT consisting of only the adenylylation domain results in unidirectional activity driving strong inactivation of GS by adenylylation and excretion of NH 3 into the growth media (29). We recapitulated these experiments in a Δ glnE mutant of Ac LP by using the Sinorhizobium meliloti derived P nodA promoter (S3 Fig), to drive expression of a series of truncated uATs derived from Ac or those previously described for E. coli (Fig 3a-b) (29).…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…(b) A series of truncated uAT proteins were used in this study. The uAT-Ec10 and uAT-Ec11 alleles are derived from E. coli were described previously (29), whereas uAT-Ac alleles are derived from Ac LP. The nucleotide sequences for these alleles are provided in S1 File.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…The same effect was achieved by expressing mutant nifA alleles that are resistant to inhibition by NifL (18,21,22). While excess NH 3 production itself is likely to activate regulatory feedback mechanisms reducing GS biosynthetic activity and NH 3 assimilation (15), mutating glnA (23)(24)(25)(26)(27) or genes involved in GS regulation may also be required to inhibit NH 3 assimilation more strongly and favour NH 3 excretion (28,29). Bacterial GS belongs to the "class I" type enzymes comprised of 12 identical subunits which are each adenylylated or de-adenylated by a bidirectional adenylyl transferase (AT, encoded by glnE) at the Tyr 397 residue, with the fully de-adenylylated GS form being biosynthetically active and vice versa (30).…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 97%
“…The same effect was achieved by expressing mutant nifA alleles that are resistant to inhibition by NifL (18, 21, 22). While excess NH 3 production itself is likely to activate regulatory feedback mechanisms reducing GS biosynthetic activity and NH 3 assimilation (15), mutating glnA (23–27) or genes involved in GS regulation may also be required to inhibit NH 3 assimilation more strongly and favour NH 3 excretion (28, 29).…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Critically, this engineering strategy does not appear to be universally applicable as P II is essential for NifA and nitrogenase activity in some bacteria (34,35), whereas it is essential for growth in others (36,37). In a ∆glnE ATase mutant of Azospirillum brasilense, complementation with unidirectional adeyltransferase (uAT) alleles that encoded only the C-terminal adenylylation domain (31) drove strong adenylylation of GS resulting in excretion of NH 3 into the growth media (29). This strategy likely represents a more universally applicable approach for engineering NH 3 excretion in diazotrophs because the ATase is highly conserved, has a specific function, and can be readily mutated across diverse diazotrophic bacterial taxa (15,(38)(39)(40), albeit the mutation appears to be lethal in the heterotroph Mycobacterium tuberculosis (41,42).…”
Due to the costly energy demands of N2 fixation, diazotrophic bacteria have evolved complex regulatory networks that permit expression of the N2-fixing catalyst nitrogenase only under conditions of N starvation, whereas the same condition stimulates upregulation of high-affinity NH3 assimilation by glutamine synthetase (GS), preventing excess release of excess NH3 for plants. Diazotrophic bacteria can be engineered to excrete NH3 by interference with GS, however control is required to minimise growth penalties and prevent unintended provision of NH3 to non-target plants. Here, we attempted two strategies to control GS regulation and NH3 excretion in our model cereal symbiont Azorhizobium caulinodansAcLP, a derivative of ORS571. We first attempted to recapitulate previous work where mutation of both PII homologues glnB and glnK stimulated GS shutdown but found that one of these genes was essential for growth. Secondly, we expressed unidirectional adenylyltransferases (uATs) in a ∆glnE mutant of AcLP which permitted strong GS shutdown and excretion of NH3 derived from N2 fixation and completely alleviated negative feedback regulation on nitrogenase expression. We placed a uAT allele under control of the NifA-dependent promoter PnifH, permitting GS shutdown and NH3 excretion specifically under microaerobic conditions, the same cue that initiates N2 fixation, then deleted nifA and transferred a rhizopine-inducible nifAL94Q/D95Q-rpoN controller plasmid into this strain, permitting coupled rhizopine-dependent activation of N2 fixation with NH3 excretion. In future, this highly sophisticated and multi-layered control circuitry could be used to activate N2 fixation and NH3 excretion specifically by AcLP colonising transgenic rhizopine producing cereals, targeting delivery of fixed N to the crop, and preventing interaction with non-target plants.
“…In a Δ glnE mutant of A. brasilense , controlled expression of a N-terminal truncated AT consisting of only the adenylylation domain results in unidirectional activity driving strong inactivation of GS by adenylylation and excretion of NH 3 into the growth media (29). We recapitulated these experiments in a Δ glnE mutant of Ac LP by using the Sinorhizobium meliloti derived P nodA promoter (S3 Fig), to drive expression of a series of truncated uATs derived from Ac or those previously described for E. coli (Fig 3a-b) (29).…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…(b) A series of truncated uAT proteins were used in this study. The uAT-Ec10 and uAT-Ec11 alleles are derived from E. coli were described previously (29), whereas uAT-Ac alleles are derived from Ac LP. The nucleotide sequences for these alleles are provided in S1 File.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…The same effect was achieved by expressing mutant nifA alleles that are resistant to inhibition by NifL (18,21,22). While excess NH 3 production itself is likely to activate regulatory feedback mechanisms reducing GS biosynthetic activity and NH 3 assimilation (15), mutating glnA (23)(24)(25)(26)(27) or genes involved in GS regulation may also be required to inhibit NH 3 assimilation more strongly and favour NH 3 excretion (28,29). Bacterial GS belongs to the "class I" type enzymes comprised of 12 identical subunits which are each adenylylated or de-adenylated by a bidirectional adenylyl transferase (AT, encoded by glnE) at the Tyr 397 residue, with the fully de-adenylylated GS form being biosynthetically active and vice versa (30).…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 97%
“…The same effect was achieved by expressing mutant nifA alleles that are resistant to inhibition by NifL (18, 21, 22). While excess NH 3 production itself is likely to activate regulatory feedback mechanisms reducing GS biosynthetic activity and NH 3 assimilation (15), mutating glnA (23–27) or genes involved in GS regulation may also be required to inhibit NH 3 assimilation more strongly and favour NH 3 excretion (28, 29).…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Critically, this engineering strategy does not appear to be universally applicable as P II is essential for NifA and nitrogenase activity in some bacteria (34,35), whereas it is essential for growth in others (36,37). In a ∆glnE ATase mutant of Azospirillum brasilense, complementation with unidirectional adeyltransferase (uAT) alleles that encoded only the C-terminal adenylylation domain (31) drove strong adenylylation of GS resulting in excretion of NH 3 into the growth media (29). This strategy likely represents a more universally applicable approach for engineering NH 3 excretion in diazotrophs because the ATase is highly conserved, has a specific function, and can be readily mutated across diverse diazotrophic bacterial taxa (15,(38)(39)(40), albeit the mutation appears to be lethal in the heterotroph Mycobacterium tuberculosis (41,42).…”
Due to the costly energy demands of N2 fixation, diazotrophic bacteria have evolved complex regulatory networks that permit expression of the N2-fixing catalyst nitrogenase only under conditions of N starvation, whereas the same condition stimulates upregulation of high-affinity NH3 assimilation by glutamine synthetase (GS), preventing excess release of excess NH3 for plants. Diazotrophic bacteria can be engineered to excrete NH3 by interference with GS, however control is required to minimise growth penalties and prevent unintended provision of NH3 to non-target plants. Here, we attempted two strategies to control GS regulation and NH3 excretion in our model cereal symbiont Azorhizobium caulinodansAcLP, a derivative of ORS571. We first attempted to recapitulate previous work where mutation of both PII homologues glnB and glnK stimulated GS shutdown but found that one of these genes was essential for growth. Secondly, we expressed unidirectional adenylyltransferases (uATs) in a ∆glnE mutant of AcLP which permitted strong GS shutdown and excretion of NH3 derived from N2 fixation and completely alleviated negative feedback regulation on nitrogenase expression. We placed a uAT allele under control of the NifA-dependent promoter PnifH, permitting GS shutdown and NH3 excretion specifically under microaerobic conditions, the same cue that initiates N2 fixation, then deleted nifA and transferred a rhizopine-inducible nifAL94Q/D95Q-rpoN controller plasmid into this strain, permitting coupled rhizopine-dependent activation of N2 fixation with NH3 excretion. In future, this highly sophisticated and multi-layered control circuitry could be used to activate N2 fixation and NH3 excretion specifically by AcLP colonising transgenic rhizopine producing cereals, targeting delivery of fixed N to the crop, and preventing interaction with non-target plants.
Non-symbiotic N2-fixation would greatly increase the versatility of N-biofertilizers for sustainable agriculture. Genetic modification of diazotrophic bacteria has successfully enhanced NH4+ release. In this study, we compared the competitive fitness of A. vinelandii mutant strains, which allowed us to analyze the burden of NH4+ release under a broad dynamic range. Long-term competition assays under regular culture conditions confirmed a large burden for NH4+ release, exclusion by the wt strain, phenotypic instability, and loss of the ability to release NH4+. In contrast, co-inoculation in mild autoclaved soil showed a much longer co-existence with the wt strain and a stable NH4+ release phenotype. All genetically modified strains increased the N content and changed its chemical speciation in the soil. This study contributes one step forward towards bridging a knowledge gap between molecular biology laboratory research and the incorporation of N from the air into the soil in a molecular species suitable for plant nutrition, a crucial requirement for developing improved bacterial inoculants for economic and environmentally sustainable agriculture.
Key points
• Genetic engineering for NH4+ excretion imposes a fitness burden on the culture medium
• Large phenotypic instability for NH4+-excreting bacteria in culture medium
• Lower fitness burden and phenotypic instability for NH4+-excreting bacteria in soil
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.