Energy limitation as a selective pressure on the evolution of sensory systems

Abstract

SummaryEvolution of animal morphology, physiology and behaviour is shaped by the selective pressures to which they are subject. Some selective pressures act to increase the benefits accrued whilst others act to reduce the costs incurred, affecting the cost/benefit ratio. Selective pressures therefore produce a trade-off between costs and benefits that ultimately influences the fitness of the whole organism. The nervous system has a unique position as the interface between morphology, physiology and behaviour; the final output of the nervous system is the behaviour of the animal, which is a product of both its morphology and physiology. The nervous system is under selective pressure to generate adaptive behaviour, but at the same time is subject to costs related to the amount of energy that it consumes. Characterising this trade-off between costs and benefits is essential to understanding the evolution of nervous systems, including our own. Within the nervous system, sensory systems are the most amenable to analysing costs and benefits, not only because their function can be more readily defined than that of many central brain regions and their benefits quantified in terms of their performance, but also because recent studies of sensory systems have begun to directly assess their energetic costs. Our review focuses on the visual system in particular, although the principles we discuss are equally applicable throughout the nervous system. Examples are taken from a wide range of sensory modalities in both vertebrates and invertebrates. We aim to place the studies we review into an evolutionary framework. We combine experimentally determined measures of energy consumption from whole retinas of rabbits and flies with intracellular measurements of energy consumption from single fly photoreceptors and recently constructed energy budgets for neural processing in rats to assess the contributions of various components to neuronal energy consumption. Taken together, these studies emphasize the high costs of maintaining neurons at rest and whilst signalling. A substantial proportion of neuronal energy consumption is related to the movements of ions across the neuronal cell membrane through ion channels, though other processes such as vesicle loading and transmitter recycling also consume energy. Many of the energetic costs within neurons are linked to 3Na + /2K + ATPase activity, which consumes energy to pump Na + and K + ions across the cell membrane and is essential for the maintenance of the resting potential and its restoration following signalling. Furthermore, recent studies in fly photoreceptors show that energetic costs can be related, via basic biophysical relationships, to their function. These findings emphasize that neurons are subject to a law of diminishing returns that severely penalizes excess functional capacity with increased energetic costs. The high energetic costs associated with neural tissue favour energy efficient coding and wiring schemes, which have been found in numerous sensory systems. We discus...

Massive increase in visual range preceded the origin of terrestrial vertebrates

“…These performance gains may explain the evolutionary increase of eye size, despite the high metabolic cost of sensory acquisition (30,(36)(37)(38)(39), but additional insights can be gained by combining the metabolic cost of sensing with the analysis of the energetics of movement (30). This synthesis suggests that reducing the metabolic cost of predation is spread across the motor and sensory systems involved.…”

Cortical energy demands of signaling and nonsignaling components in brain are conserved across mammalian species and activity levels

“…1) and chemical ( Fig. 2) events across different activity levels suggests that there are physiological factors that limit the energy associated with cortical signaling (42) and that, within the normal physiological range of neuronal signaling, the electrical and chemical events are complimentary (3). Assuming a constant energetic cost of Na + and K + pumping, there is a direct relationship between synaptic strength (i.e., average current induced by a signaling event at a synapse, which can be increased through either induced conductivity or higher probability of presynaptic glutamate release) and energy consumption at the synapse.…”

Nocturnal foraging enhanced by enlarged secondary eyes in a net-casting spider

“…Over evolutionary time, selection has presumably favoured enhancements of sensory systems that provide the greatest benefits to individuals, while also favouring low costs [1]. The often observed match between the capacities of an animal's sensory systems and the animal's apparent needs is a testament to such selection [2,3].…”