Metal clusters in enzymes carry out the life-sustaining reactions by accumulating multiple redox equivalents in a narrow potential range. This redox potential leveling effect commonly observed in Nature has yet to be reproduced with synthetic metal clusters. Herein, we employ a fully encapsulated synthetic tricopper complex to model the three-electron twoproton reductive regeneration of fully reduced trinuclear copper clusterin multicopper oxidases (MCOs). The tricopper cluster can access four oxidation states (I,I,I to II,II,II) and four protonation states ([Cu 3 (μ 3 -O)] LH, [Cu 3 (μ 3 -OH)]L, [Cu 3 (μ 3 -OH)]LH, and [Cu 3 (μ 3 -OH 2 )]L, where LH denotes the protonated ligand), allowing mechanistic investigation of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) relevant to MCOs. Seven tricopper complexes with discrete oxidation and protonation states were characterized with spectroscopy or X-ray single-crystal diffraction. A stepwise electron transfer−proton transfer (ET−PT) mechanism is established for the reduction of Cu II Cu II Cu II (μ 3 -O)LH to Cu II Cu II Cu I (μ 3 -OH)L, while a stepwise PT−ET mechanism is determined for the reduction of Cu II Cu I Cu I (μ 3 -OH)LH to Cu I Cu I Cu I (μ 2 -OH 2 )L. The switch-over from ET−PT to PT−ET mechanism showcases that the tricopper complex can adopt different PCET mechanisms to circumvent high-barrier proton transfer steps. Overall, three-electron two-proton reduction occurs within a narrow potential range of 170 mV, exemplifying the redox potential leveling effect of secondary proton relays in delivering multiple redox equivalents at metal clusters.