The
trifluoromethylthio (SCF3) group enjoys a privileged
role in the field of drug discovery because its incorporation into
a drug molecule often leads to significantly improved pharmacokinetics
and efficacy. In spite of its prime importance in drug discovery,
the stereospecific introduction of the SCF3 group into
target molecules has remained an unmet challenge. A major breakthrough
was made in 2013 when Rueping and Shen simultaneously and independently
disclosed natural Cinchona alkaloid catalyzed asymmetric electrophilic
trifluoromethylthiolation of β-keto esters. However, two key
issues remain obscure. (a) What is the preferred mode of catalysis?
(b) How is asymmetric induction accomplished? Here we report an in-depth
computational exploration into the mechanism and origin of stereoinduction
in Cinchona alkaloid catalyzed trifluoromethylthiolation of β-keto
esters with N-trifluoromethylthiophthalimide as electrophilic
SCF3 source. Three mechanistic possibilities, i.e., (a)
the transfer-trifluoromethylthiolation, (b) the Wynberg ion pair-hydrogen
bonding model, and (c) the Houk–Grayson bifunctional Brønsted
acid-hydrogen bonding model, were evaluated with density functional
theory (B3LYP-D3 and M06-2X functionals). Our calculations suggest
that, in contrast to Cinchona alkaloid catalyzed conjugate additions,
the most preferred mode for the title reaction is not the Houk–Grayson
bifunctional Brønsted acid-hydrogen bonding model but instead
the Wynberg ion pair-hydrogen bonding model, wherein the SCF3 transfer proceeds via an SN2-like mechanism. Consequently,
although the Houk–Grayson bifunctional Brønsted acid–hydrogen
bonding model has recently been demonstrated to be a general mechanistic
model for Cinchona alkaloid catalyzed asymmetric Michael additions,
this catalysis mode cannot be simply extended to an asymmetric SN2-type of reaction. The predicted enantioselectivities based
on the Wynberg ion pair-hydrogen bonding model are in good agreement
with experimental data, lending strong support to the plausibility
of this mode of catalysis. Noncovalent interaction (NCI) analysis
of the stereocontrolling transition state structures reveals that
the enantioselectivity is mainly induced by the concerted action of
multiple weak noncovalent substrate–catalyst interactions,
such as C–H···O, C–H···S,
C–H···π, and π···π
interactions. Not only has this contribution provided insights into
the mechanistic model and principles of stereocontrol by Cinchona
alkaloids but also it should offer help in the future design of catalysts
and asymmetric electrophilic trifluoromethylthiolation reactions.