Emotional reactions of medical doctors and students following the loss of their patients at the Dr George Mukhari Hospital emergency unit, South Africa

Abstract

SA Fam Pract 2010;52(4):356-363Background: Studies on death and dying predominantly emphasise the needs of the dying patient and the process of bereavement. Few studies have focused on the reactions of medical doctors and students when the patients they have cared for die. Methods:The aim of the study was to explore the thoughts and feelings of doctors and medical students who have lost patients while under their care at the Dr George Mukhari Hospital emergency unit in Ga-Rankuwa, South Africa. The participants included 10 medical doctors and final-year medical students. A qualitative study methodology using a phenomenological approach was used.Results: Meanings were formulated from transcriptions and themes were identified. The following themes emerged: emotional reactions, which included anger, helplessness, guilt and pain; recurrent thoughts about the incident; blame; perceived incompetence; detachment from emotions; religion; death of a paediatric patient; medical training; psychological services; work environment; coping with the family of the deceased; and facing mortality.Conclusion: From the study it was concluded that doctors needed enhanced training in communication skills and communicating death to the patients' families. Bereavement counselling and debriefing should be available to provide them with an opportunity to share emotional responses and reflect on patients' fatality.Peer reviewed.

You have no Choice but to go on: How Physicians and Midwives in Ghana Cope with High Rates of Perinatal Death

“…Most existing research from low-resource settings on healthcare providers' responses to death has focused on emotional distress and burnout [6,7]. Our work showed elements of depersonalization, as is documented throughout the world [16], but was dominated by providers' commitment to pushing on and providing the best care possible.…”

“…Studies from lowresource settings have documented emergency healthcare providers' emotional distress surrounding death, including feelings of blame and having to reject their emotions. These providers noted particular struggles with pediatric deaths, which felt unnatural and exceptionally tragic, as well as in situations where they were unable to grieve previous losses [6]. A South African study documented high levels of burnout among hospice workers, attributed both to the nature of working with dying patients as well as various other work-related stressors [7].…”

Well‐being and uncertainty in health care practice

“…Contrary to the traditional practice of mindfulness, which focuses on one's awareness of the present moment, reflective silence allows individuals to consider retrospective events and the feelings that were experienced. Ofri explains that this may help facilitate health care professionals’ exploration of the deeper context of what it means to be ‘in medicine’, which is likely to benefit both the health care professional and the patient …”

Constructing the health care system in Greece: responsibility and powerlessness

“…In these settings, the mistakes were often forgotten and not considered for future safety reasons, even when they were communicated to the group or to the person immediately higher in hierarchy. Masia, Basson, and Ogunbanjo () interviewed doctors who had suffered the loss of a patient during the 48 hr before the interview and one of the reoccurring themes was blame. Fast and Tiedens () showed that blaming is socially contagious, in the sense that exposure to blaming attributions regarding one event (failure) leads to blaming attributions regarding another unrelated event.…”