‘Emigration is a matter of self-preservation. The working conditions . . . are killing us slowly’: qualitative insights into health professional emigration from Ireland

Abstract

BackgroundAchieving a sustainable health workforce involves training and retaining sufficient staff to deliver health services. The Irish health workforce is characterised by a high level of emigration of Irish-trained staff and a heavy reliance on internationally trained staff. This paper presents qualitative findings from a mixed-method study of doctors, nurses and midwives who have recently emigrated from Ireland.MethodsUsing Facebook, this study elicited 556 (388 completed) responses to an exploratory mixed-method online survey in July 2014. Respondents provided rich responses to two free-text questions, one on health worker return (N = 343) and another on health professional emigration (N = 209) from the source country (Ireland).ResultsRespondents emigrated because of difficult working conditions in the Irish health system (long working hours, uncertain career progression), which compared poorly with conditions in the destination country. Respondents’ experiences in the destination country vindicated the decision to emigrate and complicated the decision to return. Their return to Ireland was contingent upon significant reform of the Irish health system and an improvement in working conditions, expressed, for example, as:‘It’s not about the money, it’s about respect . . . we love working in medicine, but we love our families and health more’ (RD283).ConclusionsThis paper highlights that doctors, nurses and midwives are emigrating from Ireland in search of better working conditions, clear career progression pathways and a better practice environment. The question for the source country is whether it can retain and attract back emigrant doctors, nurses and midwives by matching their expectations.

A longitudinal and multicentre study of burnout and error in Irish junior doctors

“…Moreover, there is a need to evaluate levels of burnout in more senior doctors, nurses and other allied health professionals. As a result of the systemic problem of high workload and low staffing across the Irish healthcare system,22 it seems very unlikely that junior doctors are not the only professional group that are experiencing high levels of burnout. Interventions for addressing burnout can be considered at three different levels.…”

“…There is a need to invest in the health service to address issues such as workload, low staffing and the pressures of a reduced a of beds. Working conditions are the main reason Irish junior doctors are leaving the healthcare system 22. A survey of doctors who had completed internship in Ireland in 2011 found that 45% were no longer working in the public health system in Ireland, with the majority having emigrated 22 24…”

Indian nurses in Italy: a qualitative study of their professional and social integration

“…None of the Indian nurses had roles of responsibility. Fewer opportunities for career advancements are common in many emigrating countries for IENs and the nurses interviewed complained about the lack of prospects for upward mobility (Kodoth & Jacob 2013, Timilsina Bhandari et al 2014, Humphries et al 2015, Allan 2016. The IPASVI Nursing Board as an institution has as its main mission to exert discipline, opposing abuse and being sure that nurses comply with their code of ethics.…”

Why doctors consider leaving UK medicine: qualitative analysis of comments from questionnaire surveys three years after graduation

“…A study of health professionals who had emigrated from Ireland, surveyed in 2014, found that their main reasons for emigrating were difficult working conditions. 14 …”