Emergency remote teaching across urban and rural contexts: perspectives on educational equity

Abstract

Purpose While educational shifts in response to COVID-19 at the state, district and school-level may have been grounded in the best of intentions, these decisions may not fully respond to the everyday realities of teachers, parents, caregivers and students living within historically marginalized communities. In addition to evidence-based and pragmatic approaches to emergency remote teaching (ERT), there is also a need to understand the experiences of students and families living in urban and rural contexts, who in light of existing educational inequities, are being further exposed to inequitable access due to school closures and the abrupt shift to ERT. This paper aims to use a reflexive dialogic approach to explore these issues. Design/methodology/approach Drawing from a larger phenomenological study highlighting the lived experiences of families being impacted by emergency shifts in educational policy and practice, this paper presents a dialogue between two teacher-educators of color working directly with teachers and administrators in the K-12 system across urban and rural contexts. This dialogue acknowledges and interrogates inequitable educational practices exacerbated by the pandemic for marginalized communities, and the shared responsibility of supporting the most vulnerable students as they transition to ERT. Findings Reflecting across their local contexts, the authors highlight the importance of educational decision-making that centers the perspectives of families in local communities; develop both pedagogical and structural approaches to address educational inequities; and purposefully approach ERT to disrupt such inequities and move toward a vision of educational justice. Social implications Broader implications of this discussion speak to the ever-widening divide between marginalized and dominant communities, which undergirds the and educational inequities that continue to threaten the academic achievement of all students. Originality/value As educational decision-makers imagine new pathways in the days ahead, this dialogue highlights the importance of keeping complex issues of educational inequity at the center of the conversation.

The COVID-19 pandemic: Impacts on cities and major lessons for urban planning, design, and management

“…Another concern raised about smart solutions is their accessibility and affordability. Accordingly, better fulfillment of smart city objectives requires taking actions to avoid digital divide ( Aguliera and Nightengale-Lee, 2020 ).…”

Design considerations in emergency remote teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic: a human-centered approach

“…As learners may experience mental and physical health issues in the wake of COVID-19, ERT design could offer flexible deadlines and accommodate learners’ lived experiences and context to reduce unnecessary stress (Mehta and Mehta 2020 ; Shelton et al 2020 ). Establishing a reciprocal communication with learners may also contribute to the ERT design as it allows for understanding the contexts learners go through and create equitable online experiences taking into consideration learners’ particular learning needs in their contexts (Aguilera and Nightengale-Lee 2020 ). In this way, teachers are more likely to identify digital pedagogy/practices that could support student learning rather than impeding them.…”

Problems of Digitalization of Education in the Context of the COVID‑19 Pandemic

“…Teaches need to prepare instructions, however, but it is still not an easy way to monitor and change the students' learning behaviors in such a short term [13]. For high quality of education professors need to understand different experiences of students and families living in urban and rural contexts [14]. The analysis of monitoring data in dynamics shows that the greatest positive dynamics and the percentage of students ' involvement in the educational process on remote technologies was observed in middle-aged teachers, from 35 to 50 years(Figure 1).…”