“…The energy stored for the triggering of the X lines and the substorm in the tail under northward IMF is just the remnant energy in the period of preexiting southward IMF [Li et al, 2008;Du et al, 2011;Miyashita et al, 2011]. Due to the weaker convection electric field for northward than southward IMF [Maezawa, 1976;Usadi et al, 1993;Borovsky et al, 1998;Petrukovich et al, 2003;Wang et al, 2006], it is prone to conjecture that not enough energy and/or magnetic flux can be deposited in the tail to form a thin current sheet and generate an X line under northward IMF condition [Min et al, 1985;Ma et al, 1995;Pritchett and Coroniti, 1994;Petrukovich et al, 2011].…”