Eloquent silences: A musical and lexical analysis of conversation between oncologists and their patients

Abstract

Objective: Silences in doctor-patient communication can be “connectional” and communicative, in contrast to silences that indicate awkwardness or distraction. Musical and lexical analyses can identify and characterize connectional silences in consultations between oncologists and patients. Methods: Two medical students and a professor of voice screened all 1211 silences over 2 s in length from 124 oncology office visits. We developed a “strength of connection” taxonomy and examined ten connectional silences for lexical and musical features including pitch, volume, and speaker turn-taking rhythm. Results: We identified connectional silences with good reliability. Typical dialog rhythms surrounding connectional silences are characterized by relatively equal turn lengths and frequent short vocalizations. We found no pattern of volume and pitch variability around these silences. Connectional silences occurred in a wide variety of lexical contexts. Conclusion: Particular patterns of dialog rhythm mark connectional silences. Exploring structures of connectional silence extends our understanding of the audio-linguistic conditions that mark patient-clinician connection. Practice implications: Communicating with an awareness of pitch, rhythm, and silence – in addition to lexical content – can facilitate shared understanding and emotional connection.

Understanding User Experience: Exploring Participants’ Messages With a Web-Based Behavioral Health Intervention for Adolescents With Chronic Pain

“…Moreover, the auxiliary visualizations (topic proportion and author proportion) that we developed facilitate characterization of cluster members’ engagement with the intervention through their textual contributions. This is a significant contribution to the body of research concerning visualization of temporal health care data, which has often focused on visualizing structured data from electronic health records [53], though there are a few examples of visualization of conversational data collected in clinical settings (eg, [36,54]).…”

A review and preview of developments in the measurement of sociability

“…A prime example of such interactions is the difficult conversations regarding terminal illness between health care practitioners and patients and families in palliative care programs. In such cases, the dyad is noted to have longer silences interspersed in the conversation than in other contexts; this has been called "connectional silence" (Bartels et al, 2016). These silences can usually be picked up by human coding (individuals analyzing the conversation) but they cannot yet be picked up completely by machine-learning models, although a mixed human coding-machine learning model shows promise in parsing out verbal and nonverbal synchrony in palliative care encounters (Schoenherr et al, 2019).…”

Re-enacting the Bodily Self on Stage: Embodied Cognition Meets Psychoanalysis

“…In contrast to silences that indicate awkwardness or distraction, “connectional silence” points to reflective suspensions or to mixed and ambiguous emotions. While clinical research is exploring pauses within speaking turns (Bartels et al., 2016; Durieux et al., 2018; Hill et al., 2018; Visser et al., 2019), in the embodied view not enough attention has been paid to communicative silence, which can convey social intentions and requests.…”