Abstract:The relationship between elevation of residence and a child's linear growth was studied using data for 8824 children below the age of 5 years born between 2001 and 2016 at elevations ranging from 50 to 3200 m above sea level in Nepal. Multiple regression was used to measure the role of a variety of household and community factors in explaining the observed elevation effect. A negative association was found between elevation and linear growth that varied substantially across the sample but retained a significan… Show more
“…Whether altitude independently contributes to child growth or simply serves as a proxy for differences in underlying patterns of economic development has obvious relevance for targeting policy and project interventions. For example, using data from Nepal, a country with a substantial number of children living at high altitudes, Shively et al (2020) find that household wealth and maternal BMI mitigate the altitude-HAZ relationship. Our confidence that altitude signals underlying drivers in a child's Fig.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Work from Nepal supports this conjecture. A number of studies find that height for age z scores (HAZ) and stunting rates have improved for children below age 5 since 2000, but gains have been largest for children from wealthier and more educated households (Budhathoki et al, 2020;Dorsey et al, 2018;Hanley-Cook et al, 2020;Nepali et al, 2019;Shively, et al, 2020). Characteristics of children and households explain most of the variance in HAZ and weight for height z scores (WHZ) in Nepal, with relatively smaller but statistically significant contributions from community-level factors (Smith & Shively, 2019).…”
The relationship between altitude of residence and child linear growth is studied using data for 630,499 children below age 5 years born between 1992 and 2016, as recorded in 47 countries at elevations ranging from − 377 to 4498 m above sea level. Regressions are used to measure the role of household, community, and environmental factors in explaining an observed altitude effect on linear growth. Controlling for birth year and country effects, and a range of factors correlated with altitude and associated with nutrition outcomes, for each 1000 m gain in elevation, height for age z score (HAZ) declines by 0.195 points on average. Country-specific estimates of the association vary and include positive associations. Results highlight the potential links between developmental risks for children and features of their physical environment.
“…Whether altitude independently contributes to child growth or simply serves as a proxy for differences in underlying patterns of economic development has obvious relevance for targeting policy and project interventions. For example, using data from Nepal, a country with a substantial number of children living at high altitudes, Shively et al (2020) find that household wealth and maternal BMI mitigate the altitude-HAZ relationship. Our confidence that altitude signals underlying drivers in a child's Fig.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Work from Nepal supports this conjecture. A number of studies find that height for age z scores (HAZ) and stunting rates have improved for children below age 5 since 2000, but gains have been largest for children from wealthier and more educated households (Budhathoki et al, 2020;Dorsey et al, 2018;Hanley-Cook et al, 2020;Nepali et al, 2019;Shively, et al, 2020). Characteristics of children and households explain most of the variance in HAZ and weight for height z scores (WHZ) in Nepal, with relatively smaller but statistically significant contributions from community-level factors (Smith & Shively, 2019).…”
The relationship between altitude of residence and child linear growth is studied using data for 630,499 children below age 5 years born between 1992 and 2016, as recorded in 47 countries at elevations ranging from − 377 to 4498 m above sea level. Regressions are used to measure the role of household, community, and environmental factors in explaining an observed altitude effect on linear growth. Controlling for birth year and country effects, and a range of factors correlated with altitude and associated with nutrition outcomes, for each 1000 m gain in elevation, height for age z score (HAZ) declines by 0.195 points on average. Country-specific estimates of the association vary and include positive associations. Results highlight the potential links between developmental risks for children and features of their physical environment.
“…The prevalence of wasting in children under 5 years of age is estimated at 6.1% in the Mountains, 6.4% in the Hills, but 12.2% in the Terai [ 3 ]. A study by Shively et al, showed that “for each 1000 m gain in elevation, height-for-age Z-scores (HAZ) declined by between 0.1 and 0.2 points for an average child and by between 0.35 and 0.42 points for a child with the characteristics of those living at the highest elevations” [ 4 ]. The authors cited several factors beyond economic isolation as potentially contributing to the high stunting rates observed in the mountains, including differences in agricultural production and micronutrient deficiencies (zinc and iron).…”
Background
The public health burden of undernutrition remains heavy and widespread, especially in low-income countries like Nepal. While predictors of undernutrition are well documented, few studies have examined the effects of political will and quality of policy or program implementation on child growth.
Methods
Data were collected from two nationwide studies in Nepal to determine the relationship between a metric of nutrition ‘governance’ (the Nutrition Governance Index), derived from interviews with 520 government and non-government officials responsible for policy implementation and anthropometry measured for 6815 children in 5556 households. We employed Generalized Estimating Equation (GEE) and multilevel regression models.
Results
A higher NGI (more effective nutrition governance) is positively associated with height-for-age as well as weight-for-height in children over 2 years of age compared to younger children (HAZ; β = 0.02, p < 0.004, WHZ; β = 0.01, p < 0.37). Results from the hierarchical model show that a one-point increase in the NGI is significantly associated with a 12% increase in HAZ and a 4% increase in WHZ in older children (> 24 months old). Mothers’ education, child’s age, BMI and no fever in the past 30 days were also protective of stunting and wasting. Seven percent and 17% of the overall variance in HAZ and WHZ, respectively, are accounted for by variations across the 21 district locations in which sampled households were located. Mean HAZ differs considerably across districts (intercept = 0.116, p < 0.001).
Conclusions
These results highlight the importance of effective management of policy-based programming and resource use to bring about nutrition gains on the ground. The NGI explained a non-negligible amount of variation in HAZ and WHZ, which underscores the fundamental role that good governance plays in promoting child nutrition and growth, and the value of seeking to measure it to assist governments in moving policies from paper to practice.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.