Elementary principals’ social construction of parents of color and working class parents: Disrupting or reproducing conflicting and deficit orientations of education policy?

Abstract

School principals, contending with competing characterizations of parents in education policy and society, may view parents in a number of ways. Two common understandings portray parents as authentic partners or, in contrast, simply supporters of the school’s agenda. This paper explores these characterizations by considering the possible link between principals’ understandings of parents and their approaches to parent engagement and/or shared decision making, especially in light of the ways that the social context and education policy construct parents of color and working class parents as deficient. We use the lens of social construction of target populations to add to the currently minimal literature that directly examines principals’ views of parents. We report findings of a multi-phase analysis of surveys of 667 elementary principals in the state of California and interviews with a subgroup of 34 of these principals. We explore how principals structured parent engagement and conceived of the goals and rationales for parent workshops, illustrating how they socially constructed the target population of parents, particularly parents of color and working class parents. We find that principals often constructed parents in terms of deficiencies and as needing to learn to better support school goals. Our findings have profound implications for advancing equity in schools.

Parent Engagement in Identifying and Serving Diverse Gifted Students: What Is the Role of Leadership?

“…District policies are the anchors for systemic structural change (Bertrand et al, 2018; Lopez et al, 2001; E. A. Martinez, 1988).…”

“They Don’t Know What They Need”: A Call for Critical Reflection in Community School Leadership to Address the Pervasive Creep of Deficit Perspectives

“…When policy makers and educators claim they want to make schools more accessible to parents and/or caregivers, they can sometimes create policies and implement practices that frame parents as "needy" and oblivious (Bertrand et al, 2018). The community schools initiative was intended to support parents, especially those from marginalized groups, to become "more engaged" in schools.…”

What students do early college high schools serve? Unpacking social constructions of the target population

“…Social constructions matter for implementation because they influence who benefits or loses from a policy intervention (Bertrand et al, 2018). Schneider and Ingram (1997) posited that when policies target dependent populations, such as underrepresented students, implementers may feel pressure "to ensure 'deserving' have been separated from 'undeserving' and that ineligible persons (e.g., 'non-deserving ones') are not receiving benefits" (p. 138).…”