In a recent preprint, arXiv 2005.03716v1, G. Wegner and C. Henkel criticized my recent work on the possibility of lossless surface plasma waves. Here I refute all of their criticisms.
I. INTRODUCTIONIn the study of surface plasma waves (SPWs), I hit upon the possibility that these waves may undergo a linear instability under certain conditions 1-5 . I explained in Ref. 1 why this possibility had gone overlooked in the literature. This was so primarily due to a historical incorrect treatment of surface effects, which resulted in incorrect theories of SPWs.G. Wegner and C. Henkel (henceforth referred to as WH) 6 disputed with my work [1][2][3][4] and claimed to have found a number of errors. In what follows I show that their claim is unfounded, partly motivated by their simple-minded mathematical manipulations while partly due to their misunderstanding of my work and some basic yet subtle physics.
II. ON CHARGE CONSERVATION