Electronic reporting of integrated disease surveillance and response: lessons learned from northeast, Nigeria, 2019

Abstract

Background Electronic reporting of integrated disease surveillance and response (eIDSR) was implemented in Adamawa and Yobe states, Northeastern Nigeria, as an innovative strategy to improve disease reporting. Its objectives were to improve the timeliness and completeness of IDSR reporting by health facilities, prompt identification of public health events, timely information sharing, and public health action. We evaluated the project to determine whether it met its set objectives. Method We conducted a cross-sectional study to assess and document the lessons learned from the project. We reviewed the performance of the local government areas (LGAs) on timeliness and completeness of reporting, rumors identification, and reporting on the eIDSR and the traditional paper-based system using a checklist. Respondents were interviewed online on the relevance, efficiency, sustainability, project progress and effectiveness, the effectiveness of management, and potential impact and scalability of the strategy using structured questionnaires. Data were cleaned, analyzed, and presented as proportions using an MS Excel spreadsheet. Responses were also presented as direct quotes. Results The number of health facilities reporting IDSR increased from 103 to 228 (117%) before and after implementation of the eIDSR respectively. The timeliness of reporting was 43% in the LGA compared to 73% in health facilities implementing eIDSR. The completeness of IDSR reports in the last 6 months before the evaluation was ≥85%. Of the 201 rumors identified and verified, 161 (80%) were from the eIDSR pilot sites. The majority of the stakeholders interviewed believed that eIDSR met its predetermined objectives for public health surveillance. The benefits of eIDSR included timely reporting and response to alerts and disease outbreaks, improved timeliness, and completeness of reporting, and supportive supervision to the operational levels. The strategy helped stakeholders to appreciate their roles in public health surveillance. Conclusion The eIDSR has increased the number of health facilities reporting IDSR, enabled early identification, reporting, and verification of alerts, improved timeliness and completeness of reports, and supportive supervision of staff at the operational levels. It was well accepted by the stakeholder as a system that made reporting easy with the potential to improve the public health surveillance system in Nigeria.

Testing the Functionality of Joint Zoonotic Disease Electronic Surveillance and Reporting Systems through a Pandemic Influenza Full-Scale Simulation Exercise in Jordan

“…For the electronic reporting systems, updating the systems to allow the sending of notifications to concerned stakeholders when new events are created, when new cases are added, and when updates and results are entered is recommended, in addition to providing continuous training to users. For epidemiological investigations, it is recommended to draft SOPs and checklists and switch all paper-based reporting to electronic reporting, which has shown promising outcomes in many countries [22][23][24]. Furthermore, training RRT on proper risk communication skills, drafting SOPs on the chain of custody of samples [25], and enhancing the documentation of epidemiological investigations were also highlighted.…”

Performance of COVID-19 case-based surveillance system in FCT, Nigeria, March 2020 –January 2021

“…Coordination of the pandemic in FCT needs a departure from paper-based reporting systems and move towards fully integrated electronic systems to further improve data quality. The goal of electronic reporting of IDSR data is to strengthen the disease surveillance system for prompt detection of public health events and real-time reporting, thereby enabling prompt response to outbreaks and public health actions [ 26 , 22 ]. The system has good representativeness as cases were detected across all ages and geographical areas of FCT, cases were also reported from public and private healthcare facilities.…”

Enhancing functionality and scaling up of the electronic Integrated Diseases Surveillance and Response system in Uganda, 2020-2023: Description of the journey, challenges, and lessons learned (Preprint)

“…The SMS platform facilitated immediate notification through a toll-free code currently utilized by the Uganda MOH. The application could also save data offline and automatically submit it as soon as a connection was available [8]. Despite these functionalities, there was a need to upgrade and add new features and functionalities to enhance the system's capabilities.…”